Artisanal miners ‘brutalised’ in SANDF clampdown:

Army clampdown has led to assaults and the property of legal miners being confiscated
The new racism: Moral superiority:

There are racist hallucinations that run unbroken through the centuries, but racism is also a dynamic phenomenon. The ways in which people are divided into races, the ideas projected onto these races and the mechanisms by which race is economically, politically and socially operationalised are all malleable. Racism updates and renews itself. It finds new guises.
To understand racism, we need to understand both its enduring fictions and how they run into the present along old grooves, changing form like mercury as they go. In South Africa important changes are happening in the public sphere strung between white-dominated nodes in the media, a set of similarly white-dominated NGOs and research institutes that seek to use this media to advance their political projects, and a group of public white figures.
Perhaps the most significant of these changes is the now fully recovered and overweening sense of moral superiority by many white protagonists in this largely white public sphere. This sense of moral superiority, as absolute as that of a colonial missionary, is directed towards both social and political issues in South Africa and geopolitical issues that affect white people, with the latter seeming to occasion its most frenzied expression.
The renewed sense of moral superiority prefers to speak in the name of “classical liberalism” or “the West” rather than whiteness but is sometimes willing to use old and crude forms of colonial language, such as directly describing racialised geopolitical issues as a clash between “civilisation” and “barbarism”.
There is no way for a white person to use this sort of language to discuss a conflict between people racialised as white and people racialised as being other than white without drawing from the foundational logic of racism.
It is true that neither liberalism nor the West, as a place or a project, can be reduced to whiteness and that there are leading partisans of both projects who are not white. It is also true that both liberalism and the West have included important white dissidents, including anti-racists, some of them militant.
But at the same time neither liberalism nor the West as political projects and politically identities can be disentangled from whiteness. This is not just because they both have their roots in Europe and have historically largely been projects of white people. It is also because they both constituted themselves against a racially determined outside, towards which the most egregious forms of racially organised oppression, including genocide, enslavement and colonialism, were perpetrated on a planetary scale.
To speak of liberalism, “classical”or otherwise, and the West as if they are wholly and plainly virtuous, and always have been, is to wilfully erase an ongoing history of racialised conquest, dispossession and mass murder in a manner that can only be an alibi for racism.
There seem to be two primary sources for this renewed sense of moral superiority. One is the turn to the right across the wider white world in response to an accumulating challenge to racism. Ideas drawn from this turn to the right in parts of the world such as North America, Australia and Western Europe are imported into South Africa.
For instance, attempts to incite panic about a wholly fictive understanding of critical race theory follow developments elsewhere, most notably the United States. This is also true of the often bizarre claims to discern Marxist logic or even Marxist conspiracy behind everything from Black Lives Matter to the concept of settler colonialism, “wokism” and the brief and now passé academic enthusiasm for postmodern theory, which was developed with the explicit aim of opposing Marxist ideas.
The contortions of history, logic and decency required to legitimate the ongoing mass murder of civilians in Gaza — along with the wholesale destruction of its infrastructure including homes, hospitals, schools, universities, mosques and churches — are also imported from the wider white world.
As with the bulk of the Western media it is striking that, in sharp contradistinction to the frenzied interest in Ukraine and Israel, wars in countries such as Yemen and Ethiopia are of very little interest. It is also striking that this frenzy has at times overtaken evidence, with the result that people who present themselves, their political tradition and their cultural affiliation as the pinnacle and measure of reason confidently make statements for which there is no public evidence. A current example of this is the repeated assertion as fact that the South African government decided to take Israel to the International Court of Justice because the ANC was paid to do so by Iran.
A second primary source for this new sense of moral superiority is the collapse of the ANC into a kleptocratic project under Jacob Zuma and its worsening failures of governance.
Thirty years ago, many public-facing white intellectuals working in the media, NGOs and elsewhere felt a need to perform some sort of humility regarding the horrors of racism in South Africa. This was, in part, a result of the moral authority of the ANC.
But, since then, the monomaniacal focus on corruption in the white-dominated part of the public sphere, which has seldom been accompanied by a similarly enthusiastic critique of enduring racial inequalities, has steadily enabled a restoration of open white arrogance.
Of course, this could only happen because existing white racism enabled the degeneration of the ANC to be misread in racial terms.
Something very similar happened in the United States after the end of slavery when black governance in the South was relentlessly lampooned in the press and its many successful aspects ignored in favour of a relentless focus on corruption. This eventually enabled a restoration of white power.
Circumstances in South Africa today are very different, but the brazen push by white donors to manipulate electoral politics from above is an attempt to restore a significant degree of white influence over society.
But the performance of white humility after apartheid, which was sometimes sincere, was not only a result of the moral authority then enjoyed by the ANC. It was also because the majority of white people had been implicated in an outmoded form of racism, a form of racism that by the late 1970s and 1980s had begun to place them outside of the norms of the liberalism and the West.
Open forms of racism had become less acceptable after World War II and the successful anti-colonial movements that followed. Nonetheless, it continued in certain parts of the white world, such as the South in the US, Australia and white South Africa. But the Civil Rights Act was passed in the US in 1964 and the White Australia policy abandoned in 1973.
By the 1980s many white South Africans experienced a strong sense of shame about their participation in what had become an outmoded form of racism. But now that it is possible for white South Africans to participate in an international and contemporary form of a reassertion of the moral superiority of liberalism and the West, an assertion of superiority that is always at least tacitly even if not wholly racial, that shame has been shed.
Another aspect of the renewed sense of moral superiority among some white protagonists in public life is a return to the sort of Manichaean paranoia in which there are always only two choices, one of which is wholly virtuous and the other evil. In this logic one is either with Israel or Hamas, the West or Russia, and liberal freedoms or authoritarianism.
This is a mutilation of history, thought and ethics. There are moral and political situations in which a refusal to take a side is a disavowal of ethical and political responsibility but one can, of course, be opposed to the Israeli state and Hamas, to Nato and Putin and oppose liberalism in the name of greater freedoms, freedoms extended to all, including the victims of the liberal West, whose lives and aspirations continue to be laid to waste.
The only measure of decent politics is a universal commitment to human dignity, equality, well-being and freedom. Neither liberalism nor the West have any credible claim to have affirmed or to currently affirm any of these values for everyone. The renewed sense of moral superiority among a good number of white people in our public sphere, a sense of moral superiority implicitly tied up with whiteness, needs to be contested.
Richard Pithouse is a research associate in the philosophy department at the University of Connecticut.
A team quietly improves people’s health in the Eastern Cape:

Well under the radar of any media, the Foundation for Professional Development (FPD) lead clinical researcher in the Eastern Cape, and extraordinary professor at the University of Pretoria, Remco Peters, is making a slow but profound difference to local health systems.
While adapting national policies to local conditions to render them more effective and creating local ownership and relevance, the FPD research unit has a single mantra: improve patient outcomes and strengthen and support quality healthcare delivery.
This is achieved through strong partnership with the local department of health, non-governmental and community-based organisations, and other stakeholders.
The projects have a community advisory board in place where the relevant structures are represented to ensure that projects are locally relevant and culturally appropriate.
Peters’ FPD clinical research team has an administrative office in East London, a clinical trial site at Ndevana near Qonce (previously called King William’s Town) and sexually transmitted infections research infrastructure at five facilities in the Buffalo City region. It consists of some 60 staff, including nurses, field and trial site workers, doctors and lab technicians.
“Most of our work is in sexual health — a good example being a project of rapid diagnostic testing for STIs [sexually transmitted infections] in pregnancy. We’re helping them implement it effectively by screening women for STIs and providing same-day treatment. For example, if a pregnant woman is positive for syphilis — a major contributor to stillbirth — we help her access the relevant drugs by sourcing where there are no stock-outs and using our leverage to get them to her clinic,” Peters says.
The emphasis is on a holistic upliftment approach as demonstrated at its Ndevana site where HIV prevention trials are conducted. The team provides support in crafting and printing CVs for participants and assists with registration for further education, so they can more easily find work.
“It’s the small things that work, really, really well,” observes Peters.
Another string to the FPD bow is its holistic mental health programme, whose data the health department at national level leveraged to formulate and implement a specific mental health objective in the National Strategic Plan for HIV, TB and STIs, 2023-28.
The soft-spoken Dutch-born researcher, who has lived and worked in South Africa for more than 15 years, is a member of several national and international technical working groups, including at the World Health Organisation.
In the four years he’s been there, he has established the Ndevana clinical trial site to ensure that Eastern Cape population is included in ground-breaking research and has early access to potential new products, implemented projects of rapid diagnostic testing for STIs and detection of antimicrobial-resistant gonorrhoea, and run other projects looking at optimising antiretroviral treatment adherence in key populations.
Peters has little time for foreign outfits that ignore their ethical responsibilities when conducting research in impoverished rural communities.
“Often there are good concepts, ideas and data generated at a local level which can be used for service improvement. But there is a genuine risk that someone else takes the idea, gets a big grant and makes money out of it. You see research coming in, for example from the US, with bags of money, doing the work and taking the results. It’s a form of exploitation or colonialism. There’s little recognition, feedback or translation to anything relevant to local people. This really puts a strong responsibility on researchers and donors to ensure that local capacity building and benefit is appropriately recognised and included in grants,” he says.
“Also, we need to be careful that incentives for study participation do not become too coercive in our population.”
Global medico-political developments have an underrated effect on local healthcare delivery, he contends, citing the political influence in the US wanting to bar the President’s Emergency Plan for Aids Relief (Pepfar) from partnering with any foreign organisation that lobby for abortion rights or provide abortions, referrals or information about it.
The threat of barring, previously supported by former US president Donald Trump, has re-emerged with threats to knee-halter Pepfar in Congress by voting against its funding unless it disassociates itself from such groups. Doing so would have a huge effect on global service delivery; termination of pregnancy is only one aspect of what many such partner groups do.
Since its creation, Pepfar has enabled the delivery of more than 2.2??million HIV-negative babies with HIV-positive mothers, facilitated prevention through 15.2??million voluntary male circumcisions, reduced HIV infection rates in adolescent girls and young women in the highest HIV-burden communities in 10 African countries by 25% to 40%, delivered care to 6.4 million orphans and other children, trained 250??000 health workers, and contributed to health system strengthening in recipient countries.
In 2017 alone, it provided HIV testing services to 85.5??million people. It is by far the most consequential initiative ever launched against HIV/Aids, with the US having spent more than $ 70??billion so far.
In a small but significant way, the FPD research project in the Eastern Cape is punching well above its weight by using knowledge gleaned over the years on what works and what does not.
Its STI projects leverage its own infrastructure to conduct sexual health training in clinics, building on the knowledge gained through its research, while insights from the HIV pre-exposure prophylaxis studies help strengthen awareness and service delivery.
“I’m really enjoying the job,” says Peters.
He found the biggest barrier in the first few months of the job to be staff members’ reluctance when confronted with “the enormity of the STI burden out there”.
“But slowly they’ve realised how much the people out there really need help in a field that’s not always comfortable to work in. You know, if it’s from the waist down, it doesn’t exist,” he said in describing the all-too-common healthcare worker and patient attitudes.
“They initially struggle to work with things like genital ulcers. But they get a lot of appreciation in return — and they find a lot of serious pathology. Slowly they’ve realised that they’re making a big difference. It’s so cool to see staff enjoying working with sexual health,” said Peters.
“I mean, they can be dealing with anything from infectious diseases to cancer, from sexual violence to happy couples that are pregnant. You never know what you’re going to get.”
Peters says the FPD tries to position its research and programme implementation resources at the interface of community development, service delivery and systems strengthening.
As his team so well knows from making a huge difference in a single patient’s life, just telling the Foundation for Professional Development’s story will hopefully put them more firmly on the radar, to the benefit of all in the Eastern Cape’s struggling healthcare sector.
Submit and get free exposure here: Showcase Your Business | Advertise Your Special Offers.

