Financial and policy uncertainty hamper SA steel industry as it gears up for decarbonisation:

About 60% of the steel produced in South Africa is through the blast furnace-basic oxygen furnace (BF-BOF) production route. The remaining 40% of the country’s steel production occurs through electric arc furnace (EAF) technology, which relies mainly on recycled scrap steel as an input.
There are several approaches that can be taken to reduce emissions in the steel sector. In the coming years, the share of EAF production in South Africa is expected to increase as the country transitions towards a low-carbon economy.
The production of steel is a highly energy-intensive process that traditionally relies on coal as a primary energy source, which is a problem for the industry’s decarbonisation ambitions. Coal is used to produce both the iron and the heat required in the steelmaking process. As a result, reducing the carbon footprint of the industry will require a shift away from coal towards alternative, low-carbon energy sources such as hydrogen or renewable energy.
The use of carbon capture and storage (CCS) technology can also play a role in decarbonising the steel sector.
All this will require significant capital investment in infrastructure and technology development, which will be a challenge for steel producers, especially smaller or mid-sized companies, many of whom are already facing financial pressure in the face of demand constraints.
The South African steel sector is part of a global supply chain, and many of the inputs, such as iron ore and coal, are sourced from other countries. Decarbonising the steel sector will require coordination and collaboration across the supply chain to ensure that these inputs themselves are produced with a low carbon footprint.
The other side of the value chain also faces difficulties because the growing impetus to address climate change is resulting in related regulations in countries to which the South African steel industry exports. The EU Carbon Border Adjustment Mechanism (CBAM) — a type of carbon pricing — will be implemented later this year and will initially cover the carbon-intensive sectors of iron and steel, cement, fertilisers, aluminium, electricity and hydrogen, as well as some precursors and a limited number of downstream products.
While several details still need to be finalised, the imposition of the CBAM could have significant implications for some African countries, most notably South Africa, which, on average, exports $ 1.4 billion a year of products from sectors covered by the European Union’s offset mechanism, including the iron and steel sector.
A working paper produced for South Africa’s Presidential Climate Commission (PCC) warns that the country’s iron and steel sector was most at risk to CBAM, with chemicals and aluminium exports exposed to negative implications too.
Another important export market for the South African steel sector is the United Kingdom. The UK is following the EU lead in proposing a carbon price on imports. The UK government is currently consulting on a range of potential policy measures, including a CBAM similar to the EU’s to mitigate future carbon leakage risk.
According to the consultation documents, the mechanism would consider both the carbon emitted in production and any gap between the carbon price applied in the country of origin and the carbon price that would have been incurred if produced in the UK.
Besides the proposed carbon price on imports into the UK, which could further dent South Africa’s competitiveness, the UK government is also considering imposing mandatory product standards (MPS). The MPS would apply to both domestically produced and imported products and would set an upper limit on the embodied emissions for individual products placed on the UK market, or produced in the UK, prohibiting products that are more emissions-intensive than the defined limit.
The iron, steel and non-ferrous metals sectors are among those that would be most affected by this legislation.
In addition, steel producers in South Africa face competition from producers in other countries that may not be subject to the same carbon regulations, such as the country’s carbon tax currently levied only by South African producers and not on imported products. This creates an uneven playing field for South African steelmakers who are trying to transition to low-carbon steel production while remaining competitive in a global marketplace.
The South African steel industry is taking bold and determined steps to fast-track decarbonisation, including hydrogen-based reduction processes, increased use of renewable energy, a shift towards electric arc furnaces, and exploration of carbon capture and storage (CCS) technologies. But addressing these problems will require a comprehensive and coordinated approach that involves government policies, industry investments, and collaboration across the supply chain to move towards a low-carbon economy effectively and efficiently.
There is undoubtedly a growing move globally toward trade policies designed to achieve environmental objectives. These measures should be consistent with the fundamental principles and basic rules of the World Trade Organisation, strike a balance between environmental and trade considerations, and should avoid protectionist measures or green trade barriers that distort the playing field.
Charles Dednam is the secretary general of the South African Iron and Steel Institute
The views expressed are those of the author and do not necessarily reflect the official policy or position of the Mail & Guardian.
US-SA diplomatic spat signals Brics jitters:

There is no doubt that the current economic and geopolitical conditions are fertile for imagining a post-Western world.
This is where Brics comes in. Emboldened by punishing monetary conditions, as well as a belligerent Kremlin — cut off, as it is, from the international financial system — the alliance between Brazil, Russia, India, China and South Africa is angling to expand its influence. The bloc’s endeavours to bring others, including Saudi Arabia, into the fold will form part of the deliberations at this year’s Brics summit, set to take place in Durban in August.
In the lead-up to the summit, which Russia’s President Vladimir Putin may very well attend, South Africa’s ties to Moscow are being closely scrutinised — each move disclosing just how nonaligned Pretoria truly is.
It is no wonder then that a recent diplomatic spat has put the Brics alliance’s smallest player in the crosshairs of the United States, which is grappling with what the current geopolitical shifts mean for its economic hegemony. The punishment that South Africa has endured so far, with the rand taking a painful nosedive, has sent a clear message: defy us at your peril.
In his weekly letter, President Cyril Ramaphosa was at pains to send the message that South Africa will not be made to take sides in the tug-of-war between Russia and the West. “South Africa has not been, and will not be, drawn into a contest between global powers … We do not accept that our non-aligned position favours Russia above other countries. Nor do we accept that it should imperil our relations with other countries,” he said.
Ramaphosa’s remarks come after the US ambassador to South Africa, Reuben Brigety, publicly accused the country of supplying arms to Russia.
In doing so, Brigety bypassed diplomatic channels and openly undermined South Africa’s sovereignty, earning him the admonition of International Relations Minister Naledi Pandor. He also tore the thin veil that exists to conceal America’s imperialist face.
Given South Africa’s already weak economic position, made worse by there being no end in sight to the deleterious energy crisis, attention immediately turned to the fallout. The rand fell to a record low, to R19.30 to the dollar, as investors digested the news.
Business Unity South Africa noted that, if the allegation is proven to be true, it will probably jeopardise the country’s trade relations with US and the West more broadly. And because the current diplomatic tensions have little to do with Russia, but with where it fits in the battle for economic primacy between the US and China, the business lobby group also underlined the importance of maintaining cordial relations between both superpowers.
Here lies South Africa’s dilemma. In the past, courting both the US and China may not have been easy, but it was certainly possible. But, in the wake of what some have called a second Cold War, South Africa’s nonaligned position may become more difficult to hold on to.
In its World Economic Outlook, released last month, the International Monetary Fund flagged geopolitical fragmentation, in the wake of Russia’s assault on Ukraine and the US-China trade war, as a key risk to the global economic outlook.

These conditions create a special dilemma for countries such as South Africa that wish to pursue a nonaligned path, the IMF warned. “In reality a geoeconomically fragmented world might entail substantial policy uncertainty for economies that try to remain open to both geopolitical blocs,” it noted.
“Rather than having their nonaligned status accepted, these economies may need to walk a narrow path amid pressures from both sides, with the attendant risk of falling out with one bloc or the other.”
The current rise of geoeconomic blocs is part of a longer-term resistance against globalisation, which began more than a decade ago after the global financial crisis.
Although the Bric alliance (which didn’t originally include South Africa) was first dreamed up by former Goldman Sachs chief economist Jim O’Neill in 2001, it was only in 2009 — after the global financial system came crashing down — that the bloc held its first summit in Yekaterinburg, Russia.
Pushed together by an economic crisis, the member states committed to reforming international financial institutions to reflect changes in the global economy. This meant creating an alternative to the IMF and the World Bank and challenging the dollar’s supremacy.
In the years that followed, however, there was little proof that the alliance would genuinely attempt to skew the global financial system in favour of emerging markets. It would take another economic crisis, and one of its bloc’s biggest bullies being backed into a corner, before its threats to turn on the US-led system would be taken seriously again.
The push for de-dollarisation has returned with a vengeance, with the renminbi making bigger inroads thanks in part to sanctions against Russia. Meanwhile, a decision to include Saudi Arabia — the world’s largest oil producer — in Brics could make it a powerful force against US hegemony. If Saudi aligns with Brics and allows member states to buy oil in a new reserve currency, the petrodollar system (the cornerstone of the greenback’s primacy) would be turned on its head.
But the US will not give up its position as number one without a fight. It has given South Africa a taste of the bitterness that lies ahead if the country steps out of line, a punishment that, ironically, is only as acute as the US is powerful. There will no doubt be nastiness whatever direction South Africa chooses. After all, there are warmongers on both sides.
When South Africa hitched its wagon to Brics in 2010, the country’s leaders may not have foreseen that it would eventually again become a pawn in another Cold War — and that whatever moral high-ground the country has clung on to after the Madiba era would be put in jeopardy. But here we are: non-aligned but swept up in a fight that will likely have more losers than winners.

South Africa’s defence minister, Thandi Modise, has strongly criticised the narrative that the country has chosen a side in the Russia-Ukraine war.
Modise told the Mail & Guardian that South Africa had not loaded weapons on the Russian vessel, Lady R, as stated by the US ambassador to South Africa, Reuben Brigety.
“I’m tired because every time we have to be told about the US. Everybody now sees the spook called South Africa. I can tell you that categorically, we did not send fokol, not even a piece of Chappies [bubblegum] to Russia. We should be left alone,” she said.
Modise spoke just hours after Russian news agency TASS reported that South Africa’s army chief, Lieutenant General Lawrence Mbatha, met his Russian counterpart, Oleg Salyukov, and discussed agreements on further enhancing cooperation and increasing the combat readiness of the armed forces of both countries.
During the meeting, agreements were reportedly reached to increase cooperation between the countries’ ground forces in various fields.
In the brief interview with the M&G, Modise said she was frustrated by the “anti-Russian phobia” in South Africa.
“Militaries have relationships. Not long ago, the Russians were here. They had an exercise. In the next two years one of these two countries will be hosting an exercise. The planning is two, three years ahead of time. That is besides that there will be other issues which bind the two nations together,” she said.
Modise said the government did not understand why every time, normal business between two countries and two defence forces took place, South Africa should be told that the “US is threatening us to run away”.
The defence minister, who came under heavy criticism when she attended Moscow’s conference on international security last year, said she expected the same outrage when she attends it again this year.
Modise was forced to defend last year’s trip to Moscow in parliament when she was questioned by the Democratic Alliance’s representative for defence, Kobus Marais. She told the house that the acceptance of the invitation was a crucial step towards articulating South Africa’s position on the need to maintain international peace and security.
“When that conference comes again, you will be calling me asking the same question,” she told the M&G on Tuesday.
“South Africa is right in the middle of trying to find resolutions for this war. I don’t know how many times we must say that we stand for peace, we stand for negotiations and reconciliation,” Modise said, adding that this did not mean the South African military could not be briefed by its Russian counterparts.
In a statement, the South African National Defence Force (SANDF) said the bilateral meeting was planned well in advance.
“The chief of the SA army received an invitation from his Russian counterpart for a goodwill visit [which] includes a call to the higher combined Army Academy and the Artillery Military Academy,” SANDF said.
“During this visit, the chief of the SA army will also have staff talks with military officials. It must be noted that South Africa has military-to-military bilateral relations with various countries in the continent and beyond. The SANDF receives numerous military delegations into the country and sends its own delegation to other countries to discuss matters of mutual interest.”
News of the army’s visit to Russia has presented President Cyril Ramaphosa’s government with another public relations nightmare as it grapples with the fallout from Brigety’s explosive statements last week.
The US envoy placed doubt on South Africa’s non-aligned stance in the Russia-Ukraine war when he vowed on his life that the Americans were aware that South Africa had sold arms to the Russians in December 2022.
South Africa fired back with International Relations Minister Naledi Pandor summoning the ambassador. Although Pandor’s office insisted that Brigerty had apologised, the ambassador was vague in his own statement.
Pandor and Ramaphosa had to quickly put out fires with their US, Russian and Ukraine counterparts.
Mathew Miller, the US Secretary of State Antony Blinken’s spokesperson, said in a call with Pandor that he underscored the importance of the US-South Africa strategic partnership and reiterated cooperation on shared priorities, including health, trade and energy.
While hosting Singapore’s Prime Minister Lee Hsien Loong on Tuesday, Ramaphosa said he had presented an African leaders peace mission to Putin and Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyy during separate telephone calls.
He said the discussions were mainly on the efforts to find a peaceful resolution to the devastating conflict in the Ukraine, its cost in human lives and impact on the African continent.
“In this regard, I presented the initiative on behalf of African heads of state, from Zambia, Senegal, Congo, Uganda, Egypt and South Africa. The two leaders agreed to receive the mission and the African heads of state, in both Moscow and Kyiv. I agreed with both President Putin and President Zelenskyy to commence with preparations for engagements with the African heads of state. The secretary general of the United Nations was briefed and welcomed the initiative,” Ramaphosa said.
Many of the ruling ANC’s leaders have viewed the move by the US as a ploy to strong-arm South Africa into choosing a side in Russia’s war on Ukraine.
The West is also said to be putting pressure on South Africa to enforce an arrest warrant issued by the International Criminal Court (ICC) against Russia’s President Vladamir Putin, who is expected to lead a delegation of government and business leaders to the Brics summit in Durban in August.
The arrest warrant has created a crisis in South Africa because the country is a signatory of the Rome Statute and would be legally obligated to arrest Putin.
The M&G recently reported that Foreign Minister Sergei Lavro, had allegedly rejected a proposal made by Pandor for Putin to virtually attend the summit.
Insiders closely linked to the negotiations said Pandor made the suggestion shortly before Ramaphosa appointed an inter-ministerial committee headed by his deputy, Paul Mashatile, to look into options on how to navigate the ICC arrest warrant.
Lavrov is due to visit South Africa next month and the host country is expected to present a list of options for Putin’s participation at the summit with fellow Brics members Brazil, India and China.
Submit and get free exposure here: Showcase Your Business | Advertise Your Special Offers.

