Former Eskom chair Makgoba calls out ‘meddlesome’ Pravin Gordhan:

“Minister of Public Enterprises Pravin Gordan is a minister with a penchant for interference and, at times, undermines the people he appoints,” according to former Eskom board chairperson, Malegapuru Makgoba.
Makgoba has described his time as Eskom chair as challenging because he had to deal with Gordhan’s penchant for “micromanagement, meddlesome behaviour and undermining the board and executive”.
Speaking to the Mail & Guardian, Makgoba said his tenure at Eskom was the “most difficult time” of his life as he constantly had to fight for accountability from others and also had to fight against political interference.
In his role as the chairman of the board, Makgoba worked closely with former CEO André de Ruyter for a period of three years. He was also part of the team that hired De Ruyter.
Makgoba reiterates these sentiments in an extract from his upcoming book, Leadership for Transformation since the Dawn of South Africa’s Democracy.
“Political involvement with Eskom was inevitable. What was worrying to me was the interference and micromanagement of politicians in the system,” he said.
He added that Gordhan regularly ignored the council and spoke directly to the power utility’s management. “This made my work difficult,” he said in the book.
Makgoba’s statements come as Eskom loses yet another board chairperson in the form of Mpho Makwana, who called it quits this week after Gordhan’s alleged political interference at Eskom.
The state-owned enterprise has been without a full-time chief executive for more than seven months, following De Ruyter’s resignation in December last year, with lack of political support being among the reasons he left.
Makwana served as chairperson for a year.
His resignation follows public clashes with Gordhan over the appointment of a CEO to replace De Ruyter. The Eskom board only submitted one candidate, instead of the required three.
The board recommended Dan Morokane to Gordhan but the recommendation was declined after Gordhan accused the board of flouting the guidelines for the process.
According to the board, Gordhan allegedly took issue with its decision to exclude people over 60 from the recruitment process. The board said the reason for this was to ensure long-term stability at Eskom, where the retirement age is 65.
Last month, Gordhan wrote to the board urging the directors to consider candidates over 60.
In their response, the board said it would implement the minister’s suggestion in their second round of candidate searches. “The Board will now also consider candidates that are older than 60,” they said.
Gordhan has dismissed claims of meddling, despite testimony from the board that he had taken four months to respond on its preferred candidate, saying that no appointment could be made because the board had failed to comply with the memorandum of incorporation by not submitting three candidates for the CEO role.
Busisiwe Mavuso, CEO of Business Leadership SA, echoed Makgoba’s sentiments and said Gordhan had disempowered state enterprise boards as they are unable to fulfil their mandate.
“Good governance starts with having a board [that is] able to hold your executive management to account and for them to do that. They need to have the power to appoint and dismiss their CEO, yet in both Eskom and Transnet, as well as other SOEs, the CEO is appointed and dismissed by a minister who can, under the organisation’s memorandum of incorporation, ignore the board in the process.”
The situation has been exacerbated by state-run logistics company Transnet, which has lost key executives recently.
“The members of the board are seasoned professionals. The minister, at the very least, can and should act in line with the board’s wishes in appointing their CEO,” said Mavuso.
She added it was not surprising that the Eskom board members would get frustrated over Gordhan’s rejection of their candidate.
“It doesn’t make sense at the moment that the minister would insist on having three names. If the board is saying, there’s only one [suitable] candidate, him insisting that they get three names is undermining their competence,” she said.
Gordhan’s spokesperson, Ellis Mnyandu, in a response on Thursday, said despite claims by the former board members, there was no proof to substantiate the accusations that he meddled in Eskom’s affairs.
“There has been no interference in the process of fielding a group CEO in this process. The Eskom board failed to follow the rules of the memorandum of incorporation. This did not provide enough information for the minister to compare which candidate was better suited. That is no meddling, it is following processes,” said Mnyandu.
Cosatu spokesperson Matthew Parks said the union was concerned that Eskom still did not have a permanent CEO.
He added that when the utility finally appoints a CEO, the new leader must be given the government’s full support to tackle corruption, wasteful expenditure, criminality, vandalism and cable theft as well as support to ramp up maintenance and bring on board new generation capacity.
But a senior ANC leader, who did not want to be named, said the fallout between the minister and his SOE departments showed that Gordhan was failing to lead his portfolio, which would be discussed at this weekend’s national executive committee meeting.
“Both Eskom and Transnet are in shambles, and they are all singing the same song — it can’t be a coincidence. It is therefore a good thing that we have considered closing down this department after next year’s general election, which is something we will speak about this weekend,” the leader said.
Mineral Resources and Energy Minister Gwede Mantashe said Makwana’s resignation as Eskom chair reminded him of mice fleeing methane.
“If you are underground and see mice running … you just follow them. Because when they run, half the time, they are smelling methane. To save yourself, you just follow them. When there is an exodus of executives at institutions, there should be a kind of methane we investigate.
“It is concerning to have several executives [at Eskom] running like mice, running from methane in a short space of time … what is the methane they are running from? It has developed over the last week. When the cabinet meets, they will talk about it,” he said.
When contacted, Makwana said he adhered to the public statement and that he and Gordhan had parted amicably.
The post Former Eskom chair Makgoba calls out ‘meddlesome’ Pravin Gordhan appeared first on The Mail & Guardian.
Hamas is intent on destroying the Jewish people:

There are simply no words. No words to describe the horror of innocent families being hunted down in their own homes and slaughtered for being Jews. No words to explain how the elderly, young children and babies are abducted and abused on camera, the parading of lifeless bodies on the back of pick-up trucks through the streets, naked women abused and spat on in front of cheering crowds.
On Saturday morning, 7 October, as Jews around the world woke up to mark Shabbat or the Jewish day of rest and celebrate the holiday of Simchat Torah, Hamas unleashed a barrage of intense rocket attacks from the Gaza Strip.
This assault provided cover for dozens of its operatives to breach the border and infiltrate Israeli territory, taking over whole towns and villages and murdering civilians indiscriminately. This dramatic escalation in tensions was persistent and unrelenting in its ferocity and unprecedented in its savagery and brutality.
Hamas is a fundamentalist Sunni Muslim terrorist organisation founded in Gaza in 1987. Created by members of the Muslim Brotherhood, Hamas is one of the Palestinian territories’ two major political parties and has governed more than two million Palestinians in Gaza since a 2007 military coup in which it murdered its rival Fatah party members.
The death toll in Israel from the Hamas assault over the weekend is believed to be over 1 000 people, and the number grows daily. This was the largest number of Jewish people killed because they are Jewish in a single day since the Holocaust.
The stories of innocent lives shattered, each containing a whole world, are heart wrenching. Like that of Doron and her two little girls Raz and Aviv, just 4 and 2 years old. They were filmed being kidnapped by Hamas and taken to Gaza. Itai and Hadar Bardichsky, married 30-year-olds, hid their ten-month-old twins in a security room in their home while terrorists went door to door in their village murdering Jews. They fought until their last breath. Their twins, miraculously alive, were left alone for more than 14 hours before being rescued.
The frantic call of eight-year-old Micha’el stays with me. Hiding in a cupboard, he phoned his aunt to tell her that his mother and father and sister had been murdered and lay just metres away from him. Tamar, Yonatan and their three children Shachar, 6, Arbel 6 and Omer, 4, were gunned down in their home at Kibbutz Nir Oz.
Images of a 12-year-old Israeli boy kidnapped by Hamas and being terrorised and taunted on camera are being shared on social media. The desperate pleas on my newsfeed are of scores of families frantically searching for their missing loved ones. Images of a young woman holding baby twins as she is dragged onto a vehicle bound for Gaza, or an elderly woman who needs medication to survive being taken away by armed fighters and then paraded through the streets of Gaza, are the stuff of nightmares.
Mass rape
The stories of the mass rape of young Israeli girls next to the bodies of their dead friends have emerged from the scenes of the Supernova Sukkot music festival. Over 260 young people butchered by Hamas were found at the site in Re’im southern Israel. The news of around 40 babies in a Kibbutz murdered, some beheaded, is beyond comprehension.
Hamas is intent on the destruction of the entire Jewish people. Far from a liberation movement, Hamas is openly genocidal in its founding charter. In Israel over the past few days, Hamas has been carrying out a double war crime — attacking Israeli towns and cities with the goal of murdering and kidnapping innocent civilians and using its own people in Gaza as human shields, and schools, hospitals and civilian structures as launching pads and storage facilities for weapons.
Hamas is using social media to document and share its atrocities, openly admitting to what many are calling blatant and unashamed war crimes. No country would dismiss the deliberate and calculated murder of hundreds of its civilians, as well as the infiltration of its borders and towns. Hamas has committed a carefully planned and funded attack on families targeting the elderly, young children and women. Once again, Hamas has prioritised the killing of Israelis over the welfare and advancement of the Palestinian people, who will needlessly suffer because of the choices and actions of their leadership.
While iconic landmarks around the globe have been lit up with the Israeli flag or in the colours of blue and white in solidarity with the people of Israel, from the Brandenburg Gate in Berlin to the Empire State Building in New York, it is utterly shameful that the South African Department of International Relations issued a statement blaming the Jewish State for the rise of hostilities this week. No empathy has been shown for the loss of innocent Jewish lives.
Jewish communities sadly know from recent decades that whenever tensions escalate in Israel and Palestine there is a marked spike in the number of antisemitism cases around the globe. This weekend has been no exception. Already there are reports of a vandalised kosher restaurant in London, UK; displaying swastikas and images of dead Israeli civilians on cellphones at a pro-Hamas rally in New York City; and chants of “Gas the Jews” at a pro-Hamas rally in Sydney, Australia.
Jewish people around the world are bracing for a backlash of hate. We have already seen marches in support of Hamas being planned in South Africa, outside Jewish communal organisations and across university campuses.
The decades-long conflict between Israel and Palestine is indeed complex and nuanced. It is of course legitimate to criticise policies and actions of the Israeli government, as well as to call for peace on both sides and to advocate for the establishment of a Palestinian state alongside Israel.
Yet the atrocities of the past weekend cannot be seen as legitimate resistance or politics. The horrific acts that unfolded had nothing to do with advancing the Palestinian cause or fighting for peace. Hamas are not revolutionaries. They are terrorists. Raping women and beheading children, abducting civilians and hunting down families in their homes is not a struggle for human rights or freedom, it is a massacre.
May peace prevail in the region and may all peace-loving people around the world call out injustice and inhumanity wherever it rears its ugly head.
Alana Pugh-Jones Baranov is a writer and the Political and Social Justice Liaison for the South African Jewish Board of Deputies. She is Deputy Chair of the Hate Crimes Working Group as well as a Steering Committee member of the World Jewish Congress’ Jewish Diplomatic Corps and its Women’s Representation Task Team Co-Chair.
The post Hamas is intent on destroying the Jewish people appeared first on The Mail & Guardian.
The Central Energy Fund’s crucial role in securing energy for South Africans:

Through its subsidiaries, the CEF has been a key player for over 60 years in ensuring South Africa’s energy security supply
Energy is the key source of a country’s economic development and this is because many production and consumption activities involve energy as a basic input. Therefore, energy is essential for the functioning of any modern economy and the Central Energy Fund (CEF) does the important job of maintaining adequate energy supply in South Africa.
Through strategic partnerships, the CEF has managed to ensure security of energy supply for the country in the midst of an energy crisis, most notably manifesting in the form of successive rounds of load-shedding.
The CEF is a state-owned enterprise that reports to the Department of Mineral Resources and Energy (DMRE). Its mandate, which is derived from the Central Energy Fund Act (previously State Oil Fund Act), is to contribute to the security of energy supply of South Africa and the region through exploration, acquisition, development, marketing and strategic partnerships.
As a diversified energy company, it seeks to grow its footprint in the energy sector and to be the catalyst for economic growth and energy poverty alleviation through security of supply, and access to acceptable and affordable energy in Southern Africa.
To effectively do this, the CEF has embarked on a repositioning strategy so it can play a strategic trilateral role on behalf of the country. This is because the CEF has recognised the urgency to make swift and informed decisions to help the group proactively adapt and be innovative in its quest to ensure energy security and contribute to economic growth.
Tasked with driving economic growth, CEF group has embarked on an aggressive acquisition drive focusing on enabling energy infrastructure geared to position the group as a credible energy investment company that will continue to invest in profitable growth opportunities across the energy value chain in Southern Africa to fulfil its mandate.
The first of CEF’s three core areas of being will be that of a corporate parent providing strategic steering, integrated leadership and driving synergies to ensure commercial sustainability of existing business. Secondly, CEF seeks to be a strategic investor and commercially focused entity, driving growth to maintain a balanced portfolio of energy investments and finally, the energy company aims to be a developmental agency supporting achievement of the government’s developmental agenda in line with its investor role and driving tough leadership and innovation.
The CEF owns entities in the energy sector with commercial, strategic, regulatory and developmental roles, housed in operating subsidiaries. These subsidiaries are the South African Gas Development Company (iGas), the Petroleum Oil and Gas Corporation of South Africa (PetroSA), the Strategic Fuel Fund Association (SFF), the Petroleum Agency of South Africa (PASA) and the African Exploration Mining and Finance Corporation (AEMFC).
iGAS
These subsidiaries play a significant role in securing energy for all. The hydrocarbon gas company, iGAS, for example has recently partnered with Companhia Mocambiçana de Gasoduto (CMG), a subsidiary of the Empresa Nacional de Hidrocarbonetos (ENH) in acquiring a 30% equity stake in the Republic of Mozambique Pipeline Company (ROMPCO) pipeline from Sasol, pursuant to the exercise of their respective pre-emptive rights. The successful conclusion of the 30% equity stake means that iGAS and CMG are now the majority shareholders, as their equity shares will increase from 25% each to 40%, respectively, with Sasol holding a 20% minority shareholding.
Strategic Fuel Fund (SFF)
The company that acquires, maintains, monitors and manages South Africa’s strategic energy feedstocks and carriers in order to ensure the security of supply is the Strategic Fuel Fund (SFF), which has partnered with the South Sudan Ministry of Petroleum to secure exploration and production rights in Block B2 in South Sudan.
SFF has commenced exploration activities and a service provider was appointed at the end of June 2022 to commence with the acquisition of Gravity Magnetic Data in Block B2 in South Sudan. The project is forecast to finalise its exploration activities by drilling wells in 2026.
PetroSA
PetroSA’s key turnaround initiatives are starting to yield positive results. PetroSA is fast-tracking its “Gas to Power” initiative to provide an early power generation solution that will leverage the commercialisation of its tail gas for power generation for Eskom or an alternative off-taker.
Through this project, PetroSA will plug approximately 180 megawatts of power into the national grid as a long-term solution to address challenges relating to loadshedding.
PetroSA has been making significant losses over the past five years due to depleting gas reserves, reducing cash balances and operational inefficiency, however, for the first time since a recorded net loss of R14 billion in 2015, PetroSA is projecting a net profit of R2.4 billion for the period ending March 2024.
PASA
The group’s efforts to secure energy for all extend to all its subsidiaries including Petroleum Agency SA (PASA). Its mandate is to promote and expedite the exploration and production of oil and gas in South Africa. While South Africa imports all its crude oil and natural gas requirements and is not yet an oil and gas producing country, it actively promotes itself as a desirable investment destination for the upstream oil and gas sector, as the country is well-endowed with these resources.
PASA has a partnership with the Council for GeoScience (CGS) to evaluate the shale gas potential in the Karoo region. This partnership is crucial in determining the amount of shale gas resources available in the country and directing investors towards viable opportunities. By evaluating and promoting its petroleum resources, South Africa can accelerate investments in the production of its own oil and gas.
AEMFC
The African Exploration Mining and Finance Corporation (AEMFC) was established to secure South Africa’s energy supply, primarily through the mining and supply of coal for the generation of electricity.
Operating its first mine since 2001, located near Ogies in Mpumalanga, AEMFC focuses on the exploration and extraction of coal, which is essential for the production of electricity in South Africa. The company is also responsible for mining operations in the Vlakfontein Coal Mine in Mpumalanga, which provides coal to the national power utility, Eskom.
AEMFC plays an imperative role in ensuring energy security in South Africa. This is through exploring and extracting minerals for energy production, developing alternative energy sources, as well as investing in education and training initiatives to support the future of the mining industry.
SANPC
In June 2020, cabinet approved the request by the Department of Mineral Resources and Energy (DMRE), under the stewardship of Minister Gwede Mantashe, to merge three subsidiaries of CEF, iGas, SFF and PetroSA to establish the South African National Petroleum Company (SANPC).
Subsequently, during his budget vote held on the 16th May 2023, Minister Mantashe announced that following the tabling of the Upstream Petroleum Resources Development Bill in Parliament, the cabinet approved the merger to form SANPC.
A detailed baseline assessment identified up to R1.5 billion in cost synergy potential (roughly 8% of total cost today) typically achievable in three to five years because of the merger. Selectively leveraging the asset base of the entities will position SANPC for significant growth, with up to R95 billion in market opportunity identified.
The important role the CEF Group plays in the South African energy sector is not to be overlooked as it contributes greatly to economic growth and development but perhaps equally important is the CEF’s role in the region and globally. As at 31 March 2018, the CEF’s business operations, investments and strategic partnerships spanned two continents and four countries. These activities are in oil and gas, technology and gas infrastructure, mining and renewables. The CEF’s footprint is in South Africa, Mozambique, Ghana and the Netherlands.
The post The Central Energy Fund’s crucial role in securing energy for South Africans appeared first on The Mail & Guardian.
Submit and get free exposure here: Showcase Your Business | Advertise Your Special Offers.

