High court says Zimbabwe Extension Permit stands pending any appeal:

The Pretoria high court has dismissed an application for a declaratory order guaranteeing the implementation of its earlier order that the protection afforded to Zimbabwe extension permit holders (ZEP) will remain in place until mid-2024, notwithstanding any appeal launched by Home Affairs Minister Aaron Motsoaledi.
The court said that the applicants, the Helen Suzman Foundation and the Consortium for Refugees and Migrants in SA, were asking for protection they already enjoyed in terms of section 18 of the Superior Courts Act.
“The applicants are asking for what they already have by operation of the law in terms of section 18(2) of the Act. Moving this application in these circumstances was unnecessary.”
The same court in June held that Motsoaledi’s decision to terminate the ZEP programme was unconstitutional and procedurally unfair. The decision had been challenged by the foundation and the consortium.
The permits, which have allowed tens of thousands of Zimbabweans to live and work in South Africa, would have expired at the end of June this year, when what had been termed a final six-month grace period came to an end.
The court remitted the decision to Motsoaledi, and ordered that pending his decision all existing ZEPs will remain valid for the next 12 months.
The minister said the ruling set a “dangerous” precedent and sought leave to appeal, but the court dismissed his application on 16 October.
The foundation and the consortium filed their application for an enforcement order in September.
They said such a declarator would ensure that the original order extending the validity of the permits for another year would not be suspended pending any appeal process. And they asked that it remain in place beyond the 12-month extension, if necessary, until all appeal processes had been exhausted.
The application was down for hearing on 26 October.
On 17 October, after Motsoaledi was denied leave to appeal, the foundation wrote to the minister to seek an undertaking that he would “not be pursuing any further appeals”. His attorneys replied that none such would be given.
It was the second time the foundation had written to the minister, the first being in August when it asked him for an undertaking that he would respect the court order, pending the appeal process.
No undertaking was given.
In papers filed to the court, the foundation submitted that Motsoaledi’s reply and his vacillation on the meaning of the court order and his refusal to confirm that he would respect it, had caused much anxiety among ZEP holders, including that they could lose their ability to continue to work in South Africa, hence the need for a declaratory order.
The court disagreed that there was a risk the feared consequences could materialise.
It said the guarantee of protection of the rights of ZEP holders beyond the 12-month period, if the order is not implemented following further attempts by the minister to appeal, flowed from the Act as well as the court’s injunction that they are protected until the minister had taken a decision following a fair process.
The post High court says Zimbabwe Extension Permit stands pending any appeal appeared first on The Mail & Guardian.
SA foreign affairs minister outlines 7-point Gaza peace plan:

South Africa’s International Relations Minister Naledi Pandor has called for an immediate ceasefire in Gaza and the opening of humanitarian corridors to allow much needed aid to reach injured and displaced people.
The steps are among seven identified by Pandor which should be implemented promptly to end the killing and humanitarian crisis in Gaza — and to get a longer-term peace process underway.
In a statement in the National Assembly on Tuesday, Pandor said South Africa needed to add its voice to a call for an immediate end to the violence — and the start of a UN-mediated peace process in the region.
Gaza has been under siege by the Israeli army since 7 October, when shelling and bombing began in response to a raid by Hamas fighters who killed about 1 400 Israelis and abducted more than 200.
More than 10 000 Palestinians, mainly civilians, have been killed in the shelling and airstrikes, which have targeted hospitals, schools, residential buildings and UN facilities.
Pandor said South Africa should add its voice to calling on all parties to “exercise restraint” and to desist from fuelling the conflict, including stopping the supply of weapons, as part of the path to peace.
She said in light of the recent comments by the Israeli government about the use of nuclear weapons, the region — like Africa — needed to be declared a nuclear-weapon-free zone.
Dialogue “led and owned by the Palestinians and Israelis and facilitated by the United Nations” needed to get underway as part of the process of ending the conflict for the long term and starting the process of setting up parallel states, the minister said.
Pandor also called for the use of a UN rapid-deployment force in Palestine with a mandate to implement the ceasefire, end hostilities and protect civilians from further violence.
She said that the instruments of the UN had “failed the people of Gaza”, as they had those of Rwanda and Bosnia in the 1990s, and called for their reform so that they were no longer just “a tool for the most powerful countries”.
The International Criminal Court, Pandor said, should have already issued a warrant for the arrest of Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu and other decision-makers over what were clearly violations of international protocols.
The Israeli government’s actions, along with the kidnapping of civilians by Hamas, were violations of international law against which action should have already been taken.
On Monday, South Africa recalled members of its diplomatic mission from Tel Aviv in protest against the ongoing bombings, which Pandor described as a “genocide in the making”.
It is also considering expelling Israel’s ambassador to South Africa, Eli Belotserkovsky, over his “disparaging” comments on the conflict.
The post SA foreign affairs minister outlines 7-point Gaza peace plan appeared first on The Mail & Guardian.
African Growth and Opportunity Act: Early extension or substantive improvements?:

On the sidelines of the 20th African Growth and Opportunity Act Forum, President Joe Biden pressed “congress to reauthorise Agoa in a timely fashion and to modernise this important Act for the economic opportunities of the coming decade”. Secretary of State Antony Blinken signalled that the Biden administration doesn’t “just want to extend Agoa”, it wants “to work with the United States congress to make it even better”. And trade representative Katherine Tai declared that the US government wants “to see this programme be more than just a symbolic one”, it wants to make “it to be more useful and effective”,
The administration’s calls to improve Agoa will be welcomed by select members of congress. Since the US ambassador to South Africa, Reuben Brigety, levelled Russian arms trafficking allegations against the government of South Africa, the ranking member of the Senate Foreign Relations Committee, James Risch, has been vocal about the need to improve, not just renew. Last week, he argued that these improvements should include “robust changes to Agoa’s eligibility criteria, management of the Agoa programme by USTR [Office of the United States Trade Representative], and oversight of the Act’s implementation by congress”.
Similarly, these calls will be welcomed by select African Union member states. Prominent Agoa beneficiaries want to see a significant revision in the eligibility criteria and graduation conditions. They want to see a shift in eligibility determinations from the current practice of once a year to every three years. They want to see targeted benefits for women, youth, and micro, small and medium enterprises. And they want to see eligibility expanded to every AU member state that has signed and ratified the agreement establishing the African Continental Free Trade Area. This includes those in North Africa.
The good news: There is strong bipartisan and beneficiary support for making improvements to Agoa.
The bad news: There is little consensus on what improvements should be made to Agoa.
The assessment: The Biden administration will find it to be very difficult to reach consensus on a specific set of changes prior to next year’s elections.
If an early extension is the desired outcome, key actors will need to find a quick way to bridge four substantive improvement divides. The first is between members of congress. The second is between federal agencies. The third is between the US government and the US congress. The fourth is between the US government and the Agoa beneficiaries.
Fearful of a two rabbit chase, the House Foreign Affairs Committee is urging members of congress to take a pragmatic approach.
After expressing a commitment “to working with our colleagues and our African partners to improve Agoa”, chairperson Michael McCaul and ranking member Gregory Meeks reminded their colleagues that “the principal consideration must be ensuring a successful and timely reauthorisation”.
The White House should pay attention to the lesson: “Successfully achieving one desired outcome is better than failing to achieve two.”
This raises the question: what is the outcome that should be prioritised; an early extension or substantive improvements?
The White House would be wise to pick one of these desired outcomes to chase.
Michael Walsh is a senior fellow at the Foreign Policy Research Institute in Philadelphia, United States.
The post African Growth and Opportunity Act: Early extension or substantive improvements? appeared first on The Mail & Guardian.
Submit and get free exposure here: Showcase Your Business | Advertise Your Special Offers.

