Locals drown in digital nomad wave:
“That the native does not like the tourist is not hard to explain,” Antiguan-American author Jamaica Kincaid wrote in her 1988 essay, A Small Place.
“For every native of every place is a potential tourist and every tourist is a native of somewhere … But some natives — most natives in the world — cannot go anywhere … They are too poor to escape the reality of their lives; and they are too poor to live properly in the place they live, which is the very place you, the tourist, want to go.”
This sometimes-strained relationship between locals and tourists has been thrown into stark relief recently, as the two groups come to grips with the reality of a relatively new phenomenon: digital nomads.
In February 2022, when President Cyril Ramaphosa first announced that his administration was looking into creating a remote working visa, the idea was that making it easier for so-called digital nomads to temporarily relocate to South Africa would boost economic growth.
Other countries wanting to capitalise on the Covid-induced rise in remote workers had already explored this option after the pandemic dealt a blow to tourism worldwide.
Two years later, in February 2024, South Africa’s department of home affairs published draft amendments to the country’s immigration regulations finally introducing the remote working visa.
But the years since the pandemic have shown that — while creating new opportunities for the tourism industry — the rise of digital nomads is a double-edged sword, having the effect of pricing locals out of their home economies.
South Africa’s digital nomad visa was the result of extensive lobbying, not least from the Western Cape government, which already benefits significantly from an influx of foreign tourists to the province.
According to data from Statistics South Africa, during almost every month last year — save for June — Cape Town International Airport welcomed a larger proportion of foreign travellers to total tourists compared with Johannesburg’s OR??Tambo Airport.
Governments around the world have had to adapt to the rise of digital nomads, said Doris Viljoen, the director of the Institute for Futures Research at Stellenbosch Business School.
“They were sort of pushed to react, because the nomads themselves made the push. The nomads found spaces and places they thought would be interesting to stay and to work from. By their mere presence … governments sort of had to react,” Viljoen said.
An analysis by the United Nations World Tourism Organisation (UNWTO) noted that the number of countries offering digital nomad visas has risen significantly since 2020. The UNWTO surveyed 54 destinations last year and found that 45% offered these visas for up to one year, while 39% exempted digital nomads from tax payments.
The 2023 report recommended that host countries carefully evaluate the costs and benefits of implementing digital nomad visa programmes, noting that their effect on tourism is still difficult to measure.
Rosemary Anderson, the national chairperson of the Federated Hospitality Association of Southern Africa (Fedhasa), described the economic case for such a visa as robust, noting that digital nomads represent a largely untapped market.
“Unlike typical tourists, digital nomads tend to stay for longer periods, which translates into more sustained income for local businesses and increased occupancy rates for the hospitality sector,”Anderson said.
“Moreover, these individuals often possess disposable income and a propensity to explore local attractions, dine out and participate in cultural activities, further stimulating the economy.”
David Frost, the chief executive of the Southern Africa Tourism Services Association (Satsa), agreed, adding that the country cannot afford to fall behind on visa reform. “It is time that policymakers grasp that tourism is a key economic driver,” he said.
But there are certain pitfalls that come with attracting digital nomads to the country. “Like with anything,” Viljoen said, “all of these positives come with some negatives.”
Digital nomads have already been blamed for driving gentrification and creating housing crises in other destinations for remote workers, including Lisbon and Mexico City. Both Portugal and Mexico offer digital nomad visas.
Last year, thousands of protesters reportedly took to the streets of Lisbon complaining that the cost of living in the city had become untenable. According to the World Economic Forum, rental prices in the Portuguese capital have risen 30% in the past five years.
In 2022, Mexico City saw similar protests over the reported affordability crisis created by the rise in Airbnb listings.
According to data from Inside Airbnb, an activist-driven website that provides city-level data on the short-term property rental marketplace, Mexico City has 26??760 listings — almost 4??000 more than there are in Cape Town, which itself rivals several other digital nomad hotspots, including Lisbon.
Cape Town has grappled with a housing crisis that long predates the digital nomad phenomenon. The city’s digital nomad-driven affordability problems have yet to reach a boiling point, but the subject has driven debate among social media users complaining that their rands simply cannot compete with dollars and euros. “Please go away. Please,” one social media user urged.
Viljoen noted: “The market reacts how the market reacts. So there is a demand for accommodation that includes everything that a digital nomad could require.
“So people want to stay there and that drives up prices, because spaces that would otherwise be available for long-term rentals to locals are now being used to cater to a new market.
“We’ve seen that in many cities. I think that we are seeing some elements of this in Cape Town as well.”
Viljoen noted that many other cities have seen strong pushback against digital nomads, adding: “I think South Africa must be cognisant that it could develop that way.”

The rise of digital nomads also stands to drive foreign investment in the local property market, where properties are purchased by foreigners to offer as spaces that digital nomads can rent for the duration of their stay. In many cases, very little of that shorter-term rental revenue enters our country’s tax system, Viljoen added.
She expects South Africa’s tax authorities will start to find ways to keep these digital nomad-induced revenue dilemmas in check.
The country’s proposed remote working visa will exempt digital nomads from registering with the South African Revenue Service (Sars), as long as it is issued for a period of less than six months within a 12-month period.
“I suspect that some people will still come in on a tourist visa and just dip under the radar — stay here for a maximum of three months, earn money from foreign employers, and go away again. Those digital nomads don’t become part of the tax system,” Viljoen said.
Sian Gaffney, a senior associate at Bowmans, said there is nothing preventing digital nomads from using a long-stay visa to avoid registering with Sars. She also wasn’t aware of any evidence that remote work visas create greater tax compliance among these types of tourists.
That said, Gaffney added that the visa has the potential to encourage foreign employers to send their workers to explore the South African market for investment opportunities.
While Satsa’s Frost acknowledged the affordability concerns created by digital nomads, he said the benefits of welcoming them far outweigh the potential downsides.
“By proactively addressing concerns and implementing strategies to ensure the influx of nomads positively impacts all residents, South Africa can become a model for sustainable and inclusive economic development in the era of remote work,” he said, adding that their presence has the potential to reduce the effect of seasonal fluctuations.
Fedhasa’s Anderson cited 2023 data showing that South Africa’s tourism recovery is sitting at 79% of pre-pandemic levels.
“We have seen many discussions surrounding the impact of digital nomads on locals and we cannot ignore the fact that the presence of digital nomads can influence local economies, potentially affecting the cost of living,” she said.
“However, this challenge is not insurmountable and can be managed through careful policy planning and community engagement. Ensuring a balance between welcoming digital nomads and protecting local interests is crucial.”
How does one fall out of love with a piece of music?
Not just any music but a classical work variously described as a “Baroque masterpiece”, “mesmerising” and “closest to the absolute and perfection”?
Known, but not particularly admired, in the 19th century, Johann Sebastian Bach’s unaccompanied cello suites were only launched as concert pieces by the “father of the solo cello” Pablo Casals in the 1920s, after he chanced on a yellowing manuscript in a dusty music shop in Barcelona, Spain.
Then, in a kind of musical earthquake, came Casals’s recording of all six suites in Paris in 1936, at the height of the Spanish Civil War.
Since then, they have exploded into universal playing and listening awareness. Every cellist worth his salt, from Mstislav Rostropovich to Paul Tortelier, from Yo-Yo Ma to Steven Isserlis, feels bound to put them on disc in a kind of grand statement.
YouTube teems with live performances, all heard in a reverential silence, as if in a cathedral.
They can be purchased in a blizzard of other transformations — as histories, analyses and explorations, “experiments in musical intelligence”, scores and study books, and in arrangements for piano, guitar, mandolin, viola, double bass and alto recorder.
But are they really so sublime? It is perhaps no accident that Bach’s autographed manuscript has never been found. Is the simple explanation perhaps that he did not have a very high opinion of the suites as art and did not feel the need to stamp his authorship on them?
Unaccompanied cello works are very rare in the literature, suggesting they do not comfortably lend themselves to solo performance.
Bach has been followed by the merest handful of composers, including Benjamin Britten and Zoltan Kodaly, in works that do not often make the concert stage.
It has even been argued that the real hand behind Bach’s solo cello works is that of his second wife, Anna Magdalena, who is credited with copying the manuscript of the composition now in general use.
One does not have to be a musical sexist to find the idea of Anna Magdalena’s authorship unlikely. She was musically gifted, but as a vocalist, not as a player of string instruments.
Experts point out that her copy of the suites is marred by mistakes, particularly in relation to bowing technique.
I first heard the suites in my thirties and enjoyed them but, over time, increasingly gave them a miss. That is in marked contrast with my consumption of the rest of Bach’s output, especially his imperishable organ works.
What got me listening again, for the first time in many years, was reading the book The Cello Suites by Eric Siblin, a Canadian rock music critic who became an ardent convert to Bach’s solo cello work and set out to trace its history.
Several things struck me on a renewed listening. The first was that as a baritone instrument, the cello is ill-suited to the clatter of staccato semi-quavers that the suites typically elicit as a Baroque composition.
It is at its most expressive as, in the hands of Brahms and Mendelssohn, for example, a romantic voice given to long, sonorous, often melancholic, phrasing.
If the typical sonority of the violin is the human cry, for the cello it is the deep, extended sob, “les sanglots longs”, of Paul Verlaine’s poetry.
In some of the slower dance movements of Bach’s suites, one feels this. The sarabande is a drawn-out courtly dance which, especially in the minor key Suite No 2 and Suite No 5, is given soulful treatment.
But repeated sequences of clipped notes are the norm in the 36 movements, and if one listens even to one suite from beginning to end, it starts to fret on the nerves.
A further irritant is the grating effect of chordal playing on the unaccompanied cello, known as “double stopping”. It is this that George Bernard Shaw was apparently referring to when he said he would as soon listen to “a bee buzzing at the bottom of a stone jug”.

Siblin tries to argue that each suite has its own artistic theme and coherence. But except perhaps in the D minor suite — where the key imparts an overall tragic feeling that Siblin links to the death of Bach’s first wife, Maria Barbara — this is hard to sustain.
Each suite consists of a prelude followed by five formalised dances, and as each of the latter has its own mood, there is no overarching structure to create an emotional gestalt.
According to Siblin, the final D major suite is about “transcendence”, which presumably means heightened religious feeling.
In fact, the two closing movements are perky secular court dances, a gavotte and a gigue.
Siblin makes a rattling yarn out of the many unresolved mysteries surrounding the suites. One of the biggest hangs over whether they were intended, or all intended, for the cello and, if so, why Bach scored the sixth for a five-stringed instrument (the cello has four strings).
There is some speculation that the sixth might have been written for a now-extinct instrument called the violoncello piccolo, which instead of being bowed between the knees, was played across the shoulders, like a guitar.
This raises the further question of whether the six suites were conceived as an artistic whole or composed at different times, perhaps for different purposes, and later cobbled together in a single edition.
When a practical need arose, Bach often cannibalised his own work. In fact, he cribbed the fifth suite, in C minor, and repurposed it for the lute — suggesting a functional outlook that viewed the suites as useful vehicles rather than high art.
Far more temperamental, ambitious and refractory than is often realised, Bach was not the German mystic, “dead to the world”, as per Albert Schweitzer’s pen-portrait —although he came closer to this kind of exalted abstraction in his last works, such as the Great Eighteen (Organ) Chorale Preludes and The Art of Fugue.
There was a broad, almost medieval, streak of the practical craftsman and court servant in his make-up, highlighted by his forelock-tugging deference to King Frederick the Great of Prussia and The Musical Of?fering he sent the monarch on a royal theme.
Players, critics and listeners now swoon over the suites — in fact, it is hard to find a word said against them. But there is another way of seeing them that I would argue approximates more closely to their essential character.
The Parsee-English composer Kaikhosru Sorabji suggests they are the emotionally parched carapace of a work. Siblin quotes him as describing them as “nightmares, gripping, dry, rattling skeletons of compositions, bloodless, fleshless, staring anatomies”.
A music lecturer at Wits University once remarked to me that “Beethoven composed some bad music … so did Bach. Actually, in Bach’s case, not bad, just dull.”
As some of the 200 surviving church cantatas from his time as Leipzig Kapellmeister bear out, not everything he wrote was at the same level of inspiration.
It’s possible that the 19th century understood the six cello suites better than we do now, in the wake of the Casals revolution and almost a century of uninterrupted praise-singing.
In a word, it is that they were études — short, challenging technical exercises for solo instruments played to improve bowing or fingering skills or to display virtuosity.
Many such academic studies were written by composers, including Claude Debussy and Frederic Chopin, mainly as a method of teaching piano.
The fact is that the long eclipse of Bach’s music after his death has been followed by a torrent of almost uncritical adulation.
In a sour aside quoted by Siblin, the French composer Hector Berlioz captured this, complaining that he was “bewildered by the reverence” with which listeners approached a messy live performance of the St Matthew Passion.
“They believe in Bach; they worship him. It never for a moment occurs to them that his divinity could be questioned. God is God, and Bach is Bach.”
The Cello Suites: JS Bach, Pablo Casals and the Search of a Baroque Masterpiece is published by Harvill Secker ($ 11.89).
Bach to basics
Johann Sebastian Bach was born on 21 March 1685 in the town of Eisenach, Germany, to Johann Ambrosius Bach and Maria Elisabeth Lämmerhirt. He grew up in a musical family, surrounded by court musicians, teachers, composers and church organists. He was the father of 20 children. Four of them also became composers.
Bach composed an astonishing 1?128 pieces of music, including
The Well-Tempered Clavier, Toccata and Fugue in D minor, the so-called Air on the G String, Goldberg Variations and Brandenburg Concertos.
Bach struggled with his sight — botched surgery on his eyes is believed to have caused his death in 1750 at the age of 65. — Source: Classic FM
Food prices top minimum wage growth:
The cost of making maize meal porridge has exceeded the growth in minimum wages, making it difficult for vulnerable households to put this basic foodstuff on the table, a new research report says.
An index developed by the Centre for Risk Analysis showed that there has been a “consistent upward trend in the total cost of maize meal porridge”, which went up by 32.9% from January 2020 to January 2024.
But the minimum wage has risen by 22.5%, from R20.67 an hour to R25.42 an hour, over the same period, the report said.
The index monitors the fluctuation in prices of all the key ingredients that people use to make the porridge — maize meal (30kg), white sugar (10kg), salt (1kg), full-cream milk (6 litres), margarine (1kg) and peanut butter (two x 400g). The total monthly cost for all the ingredients that go into making the porridge is R729.90.
These findings highlight the real daily effect of food inflation on low-income households, and support the latest data from Statistics South Africa, which showed that headline consumer inflation rose to 5.3% year-on-year in January from 5.1% in December. Food and non-alcoholic beverages were the main drivers, increasing by 7.2%.
The risk analysis centre developed the maize meal porridge price index using monthly food price data gathered by the Pietermaritzburg Economic Justice and Dignity Group’s household food basket survey to determine the effect of food inflation on poorer households.
This basket consists of specific foods and quantities that women from an average low-income household, typically consisting of seven people, aim to buy monthly.
The index points to a continuous annual increase in the total cost of maize meal porridge — but the rate has been slowing.
“The index reached its peak of 15.7% in February 2023. This trend, if sustained, promises some respite for consumers who grapple with soaring fuel prices, widespread unemployment, frequent electricity outages and a stagnant economy,” the report said.
“The … index lends credence to the notion that food inflation might have reached its zenith in early 2023 and is poised to gradually recede throughout the year.”
The data shows that the price of maize meal decreased by more than 5% from February 2023 to February 2024, because of favourable harvests and an anticipated global decrease in demand.
“Conversely, prices of the remaining ingredients have witnessed year-on-year increases, with peanut butter leading the surge,” the report noted.
Load-shedding remains a key driver of food inflation because many manufacturers resort to emergency diesel-powered generators.
For example, RCL Foods, which produces Yum Yum peanut butter, Selati Sugar and 5 Star Super Maize Meal, recorded a 33% rise in diesel consumption from 2018 to 2023. The price of diesel rose by up to 73% between January 2018 and February 2024.
“These escalating diesel costs have a cascading effect on food inflation, as retailers inevitably pass on the increased expenses to consumers,” the report noted.
It said a primary factor contributing to slow wage increases was low economic growth, which suppressed demand for labour, while inflation diminished the purchasing power of wages. In South Africa, the economy has grown by an average of less than 0.4% annually from 2020 to 2023.
Economic growth is expected to reach 1.3% in 2024, according to a recent treasury forecast.
“In addition to inflationary pressures, businesses encounter challenges in augmenting their revenues and profits in a low-growth scenario. Consequently, they may exhibit reluctance to increase wages for their workforce, leading to stagnation or sluggish growth in wages, as many employers find themselves less able or willing to offer raises or bonuses,” the report said.
As a result, low-income households have underspent on basic nutritious food since October 2020 and have resorted to less costly alternatives, which are often processed and unhealthy.

The index “highlights the extent of the national food crisis” and the need to make nutritious food more affordable, said Liezel Engelbrecht, the innovation manager at the DG Murray Trustt, a foundation focused on investing in society to effect systemic change and reduce inequality, including food insecurity.
She said 30 children in South Africa die a day from malnutrition-related causes and one in four under the age of five are nutritionally stunted.
Data from StatsSA shows that 20% of households report inadequate food, with more than “half a million of these households having children aged five years or younger”, she said, adding that the index shows that the price of maize meal is about 15% higher than it was in 2021.
Yet retailers and manufacturers are reporting high profits year-on-year, according to a 2023 Competition Commission report.
It says the cost of white maize has decreased by 23% since February 2023 but the prices set by maize meal producers — the price at which they sell their product to retailers — has fallen by only 1%.
“In addition, the proportion of the producer price that can be attributed to the farm value, the cost of the white maize, is the lowest since December 2021. This indicates that the price producers charge retailers is not directly linked to the cost of production but rather the need to make a profit,” Engelbrecht said.
This reduction, she said, has not been fully passed on to consumers, “highlighting issues in the pricing dynamics along the supply chain from farm to consumer”.
She urged the government, food producers and retailers to bring down the price of 10 budget-friendly food items that are the basis of a nutritious diet.
“While including staple starches, such as maize meal, the focus should also be protein-rich foods, such as dried beans and tinned fish, which are essential for the growth and development of children,” Engelbrecht said.
Submit and get free exposure here: Showcase Your Business | Advertise Your Special Offers.

