MK party warns against ‘frivolous legal challenges’ after defeat of 10 dismissed members:
The Western Cape high court has dismissed the urgent application by 10 expelled members of the uMkhonto weSizwe (MK) party to halt their removal from parliament.
In her ruling on Monday, Judge Kate Savage said the applicants had failed to “establish a reasonable apprehension of irreparable harm and the existence of no alternative remedy available to them” and that they had been aware of their temporary status from the outset and had been informed that their positions would “be short-term”.
The judge dismissed the case with costs, saying the applicants had failed to show they had a “prima facie right to be reinstated as MPs until such time as their dismissal by the party is reviewed”.
The 10, who were among 18 MPs fired by the MK party, approached the court seeking a declaration that they remain members of the party until their membership was lawfully terminated and that they may continue serving as legislators unless they join another political party.
In their papers they argued that their sudden removal, just a month after they were sworn in, was unlawful and aimed at making way for replacements, including former Economic Freedom Fighters (EFF) deputy president Floyd Shivambu.
Thami Khuzwayo, one of the 10 MPs who approached the court, said in his court papers that the affected legislators were never notified, either orally or in writing, of the party’s intention to terminate their membership.
He argued that no proper process was followed and said his and Isaac Menyatso’s resignations were fabricated to facilitate their removal and the subsequent appointment of Shivambu and other former EFF members.
The other MPs who challenged their expulsion from the party were Citron Motshegoa, Augastin Qwetha, Nomado Mgwebi, Ntombenhle Mkhize, Sydwell Masilela, France Mfiki, Senzo Dlamini and Agnes Mogotsi.
Last week, advocate Simba Chitando, representing the expelled MPs, argued that party leader Jacob Zuma’s responses in his court papers were contradictory.
He explained the urgency of the application, stating that the MPs were fighting to keep their parliamentary positions from being filled, adding that without the interdict, nothing would prevent the nomination of new members.
Chitando argued that Zuma behaved in an “autocratic manner” when he summarily dismissed them last month. This comes after Zuma in his responding affidavit said the members were removed because they did not possess the right skills to serve as parliamentarians.
Zuma added that the applicants’ membership had been terminated on 24 June before they were sworn in as MPs.
In a statement following the ruling, the MK party welcomed Savage’s findings, adding that the internal dispute was never meant to become public.
“They [the members] proceeded with the swearing in [as MPs], despite being informed that their presence in parliament would be short-term,” the party said. “It wasn’t enough for these recalcitrant litigants to drag the party to court, causing unnecessary expenses, such as changing office locks, keys, and covering hotel costs for new members unable to access accommodation in parliamentary villages.”
“The MK party’s voting numbers were affected due to these acts of ill-discipline by perfidious individuals,” it added, saying the court’s punitive order, “reaffirmed the party’s stance that the issue should have been resolved internally, and that the group’s actions brought the party into disrepute”.
“All due procedures were followed, and we have been vindicated,” it said, warning against any further “frivolous legal challenges from disgruntled members who failed to adhere to party protocols”.
Ongoing “egregious” attempts by individuals to “prioritise personal agendas over the organisation and its revolution will be met with firm action”, it said.
“No one is greater than the organisation,” the statement concluded.
Justice Minister Thembi Simelane to stay put, despite pressure to resign:
Justice Minister Thembi Simelane will appear before the ANC’s integrity commission to provide a full account of a R575 600 loan she received from the now defunct VBS Mutual Bank, ANC secretary general Fikile Mbalula said on Monday.
He told journalists at a media briefing in Boksburg, Ekurhuleni, that the party was adhering to its established procedures in addressing the matter, with President Cyril Ramaphosa having the final say.
The briefing followed a meeting of the ANC’s national working committee with the Gauteng leadership to evaluate the party’s poor election performance in the province in May.
“The issue of Minister Thembi Simelane is ongoing. She has been asked by the president to explain herself. From our own situation, that work is continuing, and a report has been submitted to the president,” Mbalula said.
He added that the integrity commission would recommend to the national executive council what must happen and the party would follow its processes to review Simelane’s version of events.
“She will present herself to the integrity commission. The integrity commission, upon receiving her full account of what actually happened, will recommend to the national executive committee what must happen to the comrade. That is where we are; we have checks and balances in the party,” Mbalula said.
In 2016, while serving as mayor of Polokwane, Simelane received a loan linked to Gundo Wealth Solutions, a company implicated in the VBS scandal. At that time, the Polokwane municipality had illegally invested R349 million in the mutual bank, with the transaction facilitated by Gundo’s owner, Ralliom Razwinane, who is now on trial for fraud and corruption.
Simelane has consistently denied any wrongdoing. Last week, she told parliament’s portfolio committee on justice that her loan was legitimate and had been repaid in full.
She dismissed any suggestion of a conflict of interest despite her oversight as justice minister of the National Prosecuting Authority (NPA), which is investigating the VBS scandal.
Simelane also distanced herself from the Polokwane municipality’s decision to invest in VBS, claiming no involvement in the Gundo deal and adding that it was under her tenure that the investments were halted.
Several MPs, including Freedom Front Plus’s Heloïse Denner and the Democratic Alliance’s Glynnis Breytenbach, called for Simelane to step down, citing the serious nature of the allegations. The matter was referred to parliament’s legal services for further advice.
ActionSA, which has filed a complaint with the public protector alleging that the minister may have violated the Executive Members’ Ethics Act, has also called for an independent investigation, citing concerns over her continued role as justice minister, particularly given her influence over the NPA.
ActionSA parliamentary caucus leader Athol Trollip has been vocal in his criticism and on Monday said that given the minister’s position of authority over the NPA, her “continued tenure in this role is untenable until the cloud of suspicion is removed”.
ActionSA has also written to the speaker of the National Assembly and the chairperson of the justice portfolio committee, requesting that Simelane be suspended pending the outcome of any investigation. The party is calling for a full, independent inquiry into her involvement in the VBS scandal.
“Given that the minister has shown no intention of stepping down until her name has been cleared and the cloud over her role as minister of justice has been removed, ActionSA has written to the speaker and chairperson requesting that an investigation be instituted and that they refer the matter to the president urgently so that the minister may be suspended pending the conclusion of all investigations,” Trollip said in a statement.
On Monday, Mbalula said the concerns regarding a potential conflict of interest, given her role as justice minister, would be handled by the president, while the ANC addresses the matter through its internal processes.
“We do not want to prejudice any individuals so we follow the processes of the organisation that we have set in motion,” said Mbalula.
“What an individual does in the public domain to clear herself in terms of engagement, that is her own call. She is doing it on her own behalf and it is not an ANC mandate.”
Mbalula reiterated that the ANC would not act prematurely: “We are following our processes. The integrity commission will deal with this matter, and we will await its recommendations.”
Steenhuisen to discuss vet shortages with officials:
Agriculture Minister John Steenhuisen will meet agriculture officials and others in the veterinary sector to address the shortages of veterinarians in South Africa.
Last week, the Mail & Guardian reported that vets are leaving the country by the hundreds annually, resulting in a shortage that the sector is struggling to plug. This has been felt particularly in rural regions.
In a statement, Steenhuisen said the agriculture department is making a “firm commitment to ensuring the working conditions of animal health practitioners are improved in South Africa.”
He added that the shortage has a far-reaching implications including animal health, biosecurity and food security, while acknowledging that veterinarians don’t have enough resources, medicines and remuneration.
South Africa is well below the international norm in terms of the ratio of veterinarians per population.
The president of the South African Veterinary Association, Paul van der Merwe, said the global standard is for 200 to 400 veterinarians per million people, but South Africa has only 60 veterinarians per million. He said the veterinary association receives frequent reports of practices closing in rural areas, either for financial reasons or because of staff shortages.
In its statement on Monday, the agriculture department said South Africa has 4 000 registered veterinarians.
A 2022 survey from the association showed that the majority of vets leaving the country were younger than 25. Reasons for the exodus include safety, economic concerns, career growth, the working environment and the regulation of veterinary services.
On Monday, Steenhuisen said he was aware of the gravity of the situation, given that veterinarians play a crucial role in safeguarding the agricultural sector.
“Veterinarians are a cornerstone of South Africa’s agricultural success, and without addressing the systemic issues they face, we risk jeopardising not only their well-being but the nation’s food security,” he said.
Submit and get free exposure here: Showcase Your Business | Advertise Your Special Offers.

