Mkhangelwa fit to lead ANC Youth League, not party leaders’s ‘lapdogs’, says new Eastern Cape chair:

Newly elected Eastern Cape ANC Youth League chairperson Luntu Sokutu has endorsed Aphiwe Mkhangelwa as his preferred candidate for president.
Speaking to the Mail & Guardian hours after his election, Sokutu said it was likely that the conference would endorse Mkhangelwa.
The youth league is expected to sit for its national conference this coming weekend, where Mkhangelwa will face off with Collen Malatji for the position. Dark horse Zuko Godlimpi is still to announce whether he will also stand.
Sokutu said Mkhangelwa — from the Chris Hani region, which is known to be the historical ground of senior party leaders Oscar Mabuyane, Enoch Godogwana and Gwede Mantashe — was the right leader for the job.
Taking a jab at other contenders, Sokutu said Mkhangelwa did not need the endorsement of party elders.
“History will tell you how young people have decided on comrade Aphiwe to lead the African National Congress Youth League without any instruction from ANC leaders, which is an important sign that convinced the branch that I come from, that the candidate that we should support is comrade Aphiwe,” he said.
Sokutu added that Mkhangelwa had also proven his fitness in government, having been the youngest senior manager at local government level in addition to a stint as an acting municipal manager at the Enoch Mgjima local municipality.
“We think his election and nomination by young people is the important sign we need, rather than those who rely on an endorsement by the African National Congress leadership, for them to be elected. Because as I said, the youth league doesn’t need lap dogs of ANC leaders,” Sokutu said.
“The league doesn’t need people who will convert the ANC Youth League into pocket knives of ANC leaders that want to achieve personal ambitions, which we know nothing about.
“And we’re confident that Aphiwe does not constitute that kind of leadership. And I’m saying that will be confirmed by the congress. I don’t want to preempt what they will say. But based on the motivation that was given in the branch that I come from and the region that I come from, I am confident that the same will be said by other delegates.”
Some Eastern Cape regions are said to have endorsed Mntuwoxolo Ngudle for the position of secretary general. Ngudle — who is currently heading the league’s task team — is part of Malatji’s slate in the province.
Asked if the congress would consider endorsing Ngudle, Sokutu said he would be supported fully should the conference back him, adding however that there was no indication Ngudle had received endorsement for the position.
“But I have not heard of a single structure of the ANC Youth League — I’m talking about branches — that say they want the ANCYL to have in its midst a person called Mntuwoxolo as its secretary general,” he said.
But Sokutu said he did not want to preempt the decision of the branches, adding that they would listen to the province’s regions on who they should support.
“If they say also elect Mntuwoxolo there is absolutely nothing wrong with that. On the basis that it comes from the Eastern Cape, we will go and work and lobby for that and we will be guided by delegates,” he said.
Why would amaBhungane destroy documents, judge asks:

It is hard to understand how a judge could have granted the Moti Group an order compelling amaBhungane to hand over leaked documents and refrain from publishing articles based on these without hearing argument from the media group, Gauteng deputy judge president Ronald Sutherland said on Tuesday.
Sutherland asked Vincent Maleka SC, for the Moti Group, what was said to Judge John Holland-Muter when he heard an urgent application by the company on 1 June to persuade him that the relief sought should be granted despite case law indicating otherwise.
The high court order comprised a final interdict giving amaBhungane 48 hours to return all documents to the Moti Group and an interim interdict barring it from reporting on information they contained.
AmaBhungane filed an application for reconsideration of the order and, on 3 June, the high court amended it to the effect that the news group did not have to hand over the documents pending a full hearing of the dispute between it and the Moti Group. The gagging order was not lifted, although like Sutherland, Judge Solly van Nieuwenhuizen expressed surprise at the court’s decision.
Sutherland was hearing an application by amaBhungane on Tuesday to set aside the order.
“I’m very curious to know what the judge in the urgent court was told. I have seen the heads and … I presume that that is not all that was said to the judge,” Sutherland said.
“Given the fact that it was an ex parte [from side only] application, I would like to know what was said to the judge to persuade him that the various cases dead in point against the relief sought were distinguishable in his view.
“How on earth did he manage to decide that it was appropriate to grant this relief ex parte if he had applied his mind to those disclosures, which should ethically have been made available to him. How did that happen?”
Maleka replied that he was not present in court for the urgent application.
He submitted that the documents were unlawfully obtained by a former legal adviser to the group, Clinton van Niekerk, and that by publishing information in the trove of documents, amaBhungane has made itself party to that conduct.
He said the British Steel Corporation case had established that when someone took information belonging to a company, was not driven by public interest duty and handed it to third parties, the balancing act a court had to perform must be weighted in favour of those who seek to retrieve their information, and to force the disclosure of the source.
“Conspicuously, they [amaBhungane] have not even put up a version to explain how the stolen documents came into their possession,” he argued in papers filed to the court.
“They have not put up any evidence to support their claim that their confidential source or sources are whistleblowers within the contemplation of the applicable legislative provisions. That is significant, and the court should, with respect, draw the appropriate adverse inference against them.”
Sutherland pointed out that amaBhungane has argued that the case concerned the right of journalists to protect the confidentiality of their sources.
It argues that, if confirmed, the court order would extinguish the right of journalists to receive and impart public interest information that is leaked by confidential sources.
But Maleka said it was common cause that in this instance the source was Van Niekerk, therefore this was not what his clients were seeking.
“Well then, if it is so clear, then what is the fuss about?” Sutherland asked.
“If the only reasonable inference to draw is that Van Niekerk is the source, either directly to the respondent or via the sentry, well then, so what?
Maleka replied that amaBhungane could not rely on this in refusing to return the documents.
“Well, that doesn’t really follow, does it?” Sutherland said, adding that he was happy to accept for argument’s sake that Van Niekerk obtained and disseminated the documents for nefarious purposes.
His motives were not at issue and he was not party to the case, which revolved around interdicting a media group from performing a public service in publishing matters of public interest.
He then asked Maleka, if the essence of the relief the Moti Group wanted was for amaBhungane reporters to stop publishing articles based on the information in the documents Van Niekerk released, why it had demanded the return of the documents.
“This rei vindicatio [return of property] aspect is the fifth wheel on the wagon,” he said.
Maleka countered that Van Niekerk had leaked documents containing “privileged and proprietary information” and that the applicants had a right to “dictate the destiny of the information belonging to them”. This included being entitled to argue that it was released unlawfully and to demand its return.
Sutherland then noted that in the to and fro between the Moti Group and amaBhungane over documents for a period of some three months, the latter had given the undertaking that it would not destroy the documents. It was common sense that it would not do so, he added.
“Throughout that period the respondent and the applicant are either in direct contact or in contact via their attorneys about what they want to publish, seeking questions to be answered and indicating what the position is,” he said.
“The high point is when the respondents’ attorneys make the point explicitly that the tone of your letter suggests that you’re plotting to bring an ex parte application, we give you an unequivocal undertaking we will not in any way destroy or dispose of the documentation. How on earth, on that background of over three months, could anybody have contemplated an ex party application, in camera nogal, was appropriate? Help me understand that.”
Maleka said his clients were asserting that they were trying to protect confidential information.
Sutherland said this did not escape him but asked how they could tell the court that if they had given notice of the application, which was heard in camera, amaBhungane would conceal or destroy the documents, notwithstanding the undertaking not to do so.
“This is not an application dealing with a thief who might want to destroy the evidence of his unlawful behaviour. This is a newspaper whose function it is to publish, who has published and I don’t know if National Media v Bogoshi is tattooed on the forehead of every investigative journalist but I’m pretty sure they are familiar with the fact that that case in particular makes it quite clear that woe betide the journalist who publishes a defamatory statement that turns out to be untrue.
“On a scale of between a hundred and minus a hundred, what are the probabilities of a journalist destroying the only evidence that is available to demonstrate that he acted bona fide and reasonably. The needle of probability must be close to minus one hundred.”
Advocate Steven Budlender SC, for amaBhungane, noted that an ex parte application to prohibit publication was unheard of in South African law. The media may be given short notice of an application, but notice was given.
“This was a drastic and draconian violation, not only of the respondents’ right of access to courts (which includes the right to be heard before an order is granted against them), but also of the right to freedom of the press and the public’s right to know.”
Moreover, he said, the Moti Group vacillated on what their real concerns were that drove them to apply for the order. At times it was to have the documents returned so they could establish who leaked these, at others it was to stop publication.
In either event, he argued, their case must fall.
Deviations from the audi alteram partem rule required truly compelling reasons, he said.
But there were no exceptional circumstances because the applicants did not even meet the standard of “a real and well-founded apprehension that this evidence may be hidden or destroyed” which applies in so-called Anton Pillar orders, which are considered draconian and only granted as a temporary form of relief.
Here the court had gone beyond that to grant final relief, without hearing from amaBhungane, that once implemented would mean the Moti Group would irrevocably know what documents had been leaked to them and by whom. It would have the twin effect of depriving amaBhungane of their source material.
“There is simply no authority for the notion that such relief can be obtained on an ex parte basis,” Budlender said.
“On the contrary, the fact that all of the authorities on Anton Piller orders restrict such orders to interim procedural relief, and that these orders are described as the ‘outer extreme of judicial power’, supports the conclusion that substantive relief can never be obtained against a respondent without notice.
It was granted, Budlender said, on the strength of the say-so of the applicants that amaBhungane would destroy the documents while there was no evidence to support this.
The Moti Group’s case was simply that if someone stole a document and gave it to the press then both the person who leaked the document and the press are guilty of a crime and the person to whom the document belonged could obtain a court order without even citing the media in question.
“That is an extraordinary proposition and it is one that is incredibly damaging in our democratic state. After all, if they are right, then the Guptas just missed a trick. The moment there was first a mention of the Gupta leaks they should have run off to court.”
It was simply wrong in law, Budlender said, because it was not unlawful for journalists to receive and retain leaked information, regardless of the source and because rei vindicatio relief did not apply in this kind of case.
The Moti Group was not arguing that amaBhungane was in possession of original documents belonging to them, but of copies made by Van Niekerk.
“There is no proprietary interest in the copies or the information contained in them. And the applicants cannot vindicate that which is already in their possession,” Budlender said.
The group, founded by Zunaid Moti, has extensive mining interests in Zimbabwe.
The articles amaBhungane has published showed that Moti sought to ingratiate himself with Zimbabwe’s political elites, and revealed financial flows through the Moti Group in that country, as well as a secret loan to an Investec employee tasked with limiting the bank’s exposure to the Moti Group’s debt.
- This article has been updated with argument in court on behalf of amaBhungane.
Inequality is man-made — and there’s nothing like a pandemic to expose it:

If you were a South African health journalist, like me, during the late 1990s and early 2000s, you were mostly an Aids reporter. Eight out of 10 stories you produced would have been about the epidemic.
It was a time of unprecedented Aids-related deaths, government policy based on politics rather than science and activism that, in many respects, was as fierce as the fight against apartheid.
I was a cub reporter, with limited insight, for the public broadcaster then, but following HIV during a controversial time when the government refused to provide lifesaving antiretroviral drugs to people infected with the virus quickly taught me an important thing: a pandemic isn’t simply a disease gone viral.
It’s a political, social, economic and human rights crisis, because the germ which caused the outbreak travels through a society ravaged by inequality.
There’s nothing like a pandemic to expose what’s working and what’s not. Disease outbreaks are like magnifying glasses, they amplify everything — and our responses to such events are recorded.
HIV and our more recent pandemic, Covid-19, for example, laid bare that inequality didn’t just appear from some hidden realm. It’s man-made. As the head of UNAids, Winnie Byanyima, aptly put it in a recent webinar: “Inequalities are a policy choice. They are choices our governments make.”
Research shows inequality is one of the main reasons we still see Aids-related deaths in an era where we have all the antiretrovirals, HIV prevention pills, vaginal rings, injections and harm-reduction plans we need to end the pandemic.
It was also one of the chief causes of so many unnecessary Covid-19 deaths.
Why? Because inequalities, which we’ve normalised — such as women having less power than men, prejudice against gay and transgender people, making sex workers and drug users feel they’re not human enough to be served at clinics — frequently make it impossible to get lifesaving medicine to those who need it the most.
Getting scientists to develop medicine that cures an illness, prevents it or turns it into a chronic disease that can be managed with medication is, therefore, a relatively small part of the solution. The more difficult thing is to get the pills, injections, vaccines, whatever it may be, to people who need them — and to then to use it.
ARVs work
HIV and Covid-19 have shown us that just because there are pills or measures that science has proven can save lives, doesn’t mean people will necessarily take up the offer — people’s views on life, and their trust in the providers of such medication, influence their decisions.
During Covid-19, for instance, whether someone got vaccinated or masked up, had a lot to do with their political ideologies or religions. A 2021 study by The Economist showed that the single biggest indicator of whether Americans would get vaccinated was who they voted for during the 2020 elections: supporters of the Republican Party’s former United States president, Donald Trump, were 18 percentage points more likely to shun Covid-19 vaccines than those who voted for the Democratic Party’s Joe Biden.
And in South Africa, home to an estimated 7.9-million people with HIV, 94% of infected people have been diagnosed, but of those who know that they’ve contracted the virus, only 77% are on treatment, Health Minister Joe Phaahla announced at last week’s South African Aids conference in Durban.
So, despite studies that show antiretroviral treatment (ART), if started in time, can increase an HIV-positive person’s life expectancy to almost the same age as that of uninfected people, 23% of diagnosed people in our country have chosen not to be on treatment.
For many of those untreated people, this is not a deliberate choice; society or their living conditions made the choice for them.
Francois Venter, an infectious disease specialist and head of the health organisation, Ezintsha, points out: “We have testing available, and I think most people understand treatment is free and readily available and safe and effective. But things like denial, stigma, unfriendly services, and simply the hassle factor for people with busy and full lives, may all be contributing.”
Treatment at clinics
Take stigma, for example. When researchers from Ritshidze, a group of organisations that represent people with HIV, asked transgender people, men who have sex with men, sex workers and injecting drug users in South Africa about how they’re treated at government clinics, less than half, and in some cases not even a quarter, of the more than 9 000 respondents reported being greeted by a friendly face. In some of these groups, about one in five people said they’ve been blocked from getting health services.
People from these key populations have a higher chance of getting HIV than the general population — but knowing that they will be discriminated against, they stop going to clinics altogether, James Oladipo, one of the Ritshidze report’s authors, told Bhekisisa in May.
To address this, the health department is now providing training to health workers to help them better understand transgender people, sex workers and men who have sex with men, so that they stop discriminating against those groups, the department’s acting head of HIV, Thato Chidarikire, says.
“This training has video clips [where real people share their] experiences. [For example] there’s a chapter on transgender people, with a trans person talking about their experience at a [health] facility… [The curriculum] starts from the basics, from [people’s] reality. What we’re trying to [achieve is] to say, “Be sensitive, be competent.”
Social justice work
Byanyima says solving inequality requires formal agreed-upon rules, in the form of policies — because we can’t control people or governments’ day-to-day decisions without it.
And because epidemics play out in societies with politics, and economic and social orders, the answer to putting a stop to outbreaks that thrive in the midst of inequality lies in creating policies to get these sectors to work together, rather than merely making available medication at hospitals and clinics.
The late American medical anthropologist and physician, Paul Farmer, who spent a large part of his career bringing high-quality services to poorer countries such as Haiti by fighting inequality, explained it well in an interview with the Boston Globe in 2008: “Medicine should be viewed as social justice work in a world that is so sick and riven by inequities.”
So what do policy solutions to inequality look like?
Byanyima says we can learn a lot from the partnerships organisations in South Africa formed during our fight for access to HIV treatment. To get the government to change its policy of not providing antiretroviral treatment in the late 1990s and early 2000s, lawyers, scientists, doctors, economists, human rights activists, journalists and communities of people living with HIV joined hands to stand up to the state.
As a result, about four years into the battle, in 2002, the constitutional court ordered the then minister of health, Manto Tshabalala-Msimang, to provide HIV-positive pregnant women with antiretroviral drugs that could prevent them from infecting their babies, and in 2004 HIV treatment was expanded to the broader public.
As a direct consequence of that court decision, and the pressure it put on the government to make free HIV treatment available widely, the annual death rate among black Africans, who make up the largest part of South Africa’s HIV cases, has decreased by 31% between 2006 and 2016 and the likelihood of someone reporting bad health is down by almost half. And in this case too, inequality has navigated the virus’s spread: studies have found that racist apartheid policies of “residential segregation”, of which the aftermath still restricts this demographic group’s access to health facilities, have strongly influenced this group’s high infection rate.
Uganda’s anti-gay laws
But South Africa’s fight against inequality should extend across its borders, says the South African National Aids Control Council’s Steve Letsike. “Why are we [the government] bystanders when countries such as Uganda, Ghana, Kenya, Tanzania and Namibia introduce anti-homosexuality laws that seek to erase LGBTIQ+ people?” she asked at the Aids conference. “It undermines the health agenda. Injustice there means injustice where we are.”
In May, Uganda’s President, Yoweri Museveni signed the country’s anti-homesexuality Bill into law. The Act extends the possible punishment for certain types of gay sex from life imprisonment to the death penalty. The new law also creates new crimes such as the “promotion of homesexuality” and increases the prison sentence for “attempted same-sex” sexual relations to 10 years.
“This Act is truly draconian and will lead to even more hate crimes and human rights violations against people who identify as LGBTIQ+ in a country where homophobia and transphobia is already rampant,” Letsike warns.
This legislation will, undoubtedly, also lead to fewer LGBTIQ+ people accessing HIV services, and many new infections.
Research in 10 sub-Saharan African countries found that gay and other men who have sex with men who lived in countries that criminalised same-sex sexual activities, were twice as likely to be infected with HIV compared to countries where it was legal. This increased to eight times more likely in countries with “severely criminalised” environments such as Uganda.
One of the main reasons for this group’s higher likelihood to be HIV positive in countries with anti-gay laws, is that it makes it difficult for people with same-sex relations to visit health facilities to get tested or treated for HIV, because they fear arrest if their sexuality is discovered by health workers.
Byanyima, whose home country is Uganda, says the missing ingredient to fight inequality is the political will of countries to make “tough choices to invest in people to end Aids”.
Evidence, not morals
Political will and a tendency to allow prejudice and morals trump science.
For example, despite HIV treatment and prevention pills that can reduce someone’s chances of getting HIV through sex by 99%, Aids is still the leading cause of death among women in Africa (after maternal mortality), says UNAids. Yet many teenage girls, who are about three times as likely to become infected than teenage boys, live in countries where they’re not allowed to get tested for HIV or to obtain contraception on their own — they can only do so with parental consent.
Such “moralistic” laws, which are often intended to stop teenagers from having sex, frequently achieve the opposite. Research shows that in African countries where the age of consent for HIV testing is 15 years or lower, teenagers are 74% more likely to have been tested for HIV in the last year than in countries where the age of consent is 16 years or higher.
The policy choices governments make, and the values they use to make them, will determine how fast — or slow — we end inequality and the pandemics inequality fuels.
How inclusive we’re prepared to be will, in the end, frame our future.
We need to constantly remind ourselves of an important question that Farmer often asked: “If access to healthcare is a human right, who is human enough to receive it?”

This story was produced by the Bhekisisa Centre for Health Journalism. Sign up for the newsletter.
Submit and get free exposure here: Showcase Your Business | Advertise Your Special Offers.

