Rise of canola production in SA an inspiration for other value chains:
Many crops and their related value chains have shown dramatic progress in recent years. This should inspire further growth in this sector.
I often write about South Africa’s soybean success story, involving an increase from 67 700 tonnes in the 1993-94 production season to an expected 2.3 million tonnes in 2024-25. This, in turn, has been driven by an increase in the demand for high-protein food, particularly poultry products.
But soybeans aren’t the only winners in South Africa’s vegetable oils cluster. Canola is also an agricultural success story.
Since South African farmers planted the crop commercially on 17 000 hectares in 1998-99, the area has increased to an estimated 165 750 hectares in 2024-25. For the new season of 2025-26, the farmers plan to increase the area to 166 500 hectares.
Like soybeans, the catalyst behind the increase in canola plantings is a rise in domestic demand for, and use of, oils and oilcake. South Africa is now a net canola exporter, having recently exported to countries such as Germany and Belgium.
There has been a switch in traditional winter wheat and barley-growing areas to canola because of the firm demand and the price competitiveness. Canola is a winter crop, hence, production is primarily in the Western Cape, a winter rainfall region.
The farmers intend to plant 166 500 hectares, up by 0.5% from the previous season. If we assume relatively favourable weather conditions and a decent yield, applying a five-year average yield of 1 89 tonnes a hectare, South Africa looks set to harvest 314 685 tonnes, up 9% from the previous season. This could be a fresh high.
Admittedly, it is still too early to tell with certainty where the canola crop harvest will be and whether farmers will manage to plant the area they intend to. The key determinant will be the weather conditions. Fortunately, the weather has turned positive, promising some showers in the Western Cape in the last two weeks of May. Under this assumption, we can remain optimistic.
Putting the current weather forecasts aside, I think it’s fair to say that canola is one of the success stories of South African agriculture, belonging in the same category as the soybean industry and many of our fruits.
From now on, the objective is to see increases in various commodities, such as canola, and general improvement in agriculture in the parts of the country that haven’t been part of the success story, like the former homelands.
But for that to materialise, we need coordinated support and effective collaboration between the government and business. The government will need to do its part to improve land governance, while leaning on commodity associations for support in unlocking the agricultural value of these regions at the periphery of South Africa’s agricultural achievers.
This is an important step, not only for crops and fruits, but also for livestock and the poultry industries, which are already the key value chains with better penetration in the former homelands regions.
Again, as I have said several times, the effort to realise this ambition does not require new planting. We already have the Agriculture and Agro-processing Master Plan, which is broadly embraced by agricultural stakeholders and other social partners and was co-created by all.
The plan seeks to improve South Africa’s agriculture by unlocking various hindrances in key value chains and takes a commodity-specific approach. Importantly, it is also clear on what value chains could thrive in multiple regions. What is left is for it to be fully implemented.
My book, A Country of Two Agricultures, advances this ambition and clearly states South Africa’s policy approaches to drive progress in the sector.
The success of South Africa’s canola industry should inspire others in the agricultural sector.
Wandile Sihlobo is the chief economist of the Agricultural Business Chamber of South Africa.
Trade unions, return to your socialist values and origins:
Labour union federation Cosatu made famous the slogan “An injury to one is an injury to all.” The organisation was said to be more than just a federation of unions; their unions adopted the Freedom Charter and their demands were not limited to wages and conditions of service, but also what type of society they wanted South Africa to be.
But, in the post-1994 era, Cosatu hinged all workers’ demands on their opposition to the government’s macroeconomic strategy, the conservative Growth, Employment and Redistribution policy. Their growth in the private sector, even as types of work changed, was limited.
One of the problems facing trade unions is that businesses constantly come up with different ways to bypass them.
In your local supermarket chain that carry national franchises, the majority of cashiers, store packers and so forth are members of a trade union, probably the Cosatu-affiliated South African Commercial, Catering and Allied Workers Union.
But the motor bike delivery drivers are not unionised. They are not even employees of the company. They are categorised as independent contractors.
This phenomena began in the early 2000s with what became known as owner-driver schemes. Previously companies such as Coca-Cola and Dairy Belle owned the trucks and employed the drivers.
Owner-driver schemes were presented as an empowerment model. The driver would sign an agreement with the company to deliver their goods to various parts of the country and, based on that agreement, they would then receive a loan and purchase the delivery truck. It seemed like a great model and allowed employees to become entrepreneurs. Owner-driver schemes flourished and mining companies also began using similar models.
Upon closer inspection, you begin to realise that this is not empowerment, but rather the company is mitigating its risk and passing it on to its former employee. The drivers receive no job security and lose employee benefits such as sick leave and pensions. It is just another outsourcing model.
The retail sector, where the packers and cashiers are unionised but the delivery workers are not, is a classic example of divide and rule. The expectation is that soon walk-in stores will be an abnormality and the number of cashiers and merchandisers will decrease, because the store will become a warehouse for the internet delivery worker to pick up the order. There is little worker solidarity between the delivery worker and the in-store staff.
So do trade unions still organise workers? We know that trade unions exist, but are they still a revolutionary force on the ground? Do people, even if they are not members of a trade union, still believe that a trade union really wants a better country for all?
It’s not that South Africans have become jaded and cynical, but many have discarded their commitment to revolutionary ideals, because they witnessed their leaders dump it first.
Most of the public sector is unionised, and very many people will testify how bad the services are in public institutions. The revolutionary garments of the trade union leadership and their members seem quite frayed and tired.
South Africans are not fooled by the revolutionary rhetoric about workers and a socialist state. They know that this is a pantomime and not the real focus. Trade unions seem more focused on keeping what they have from other trade unions, rather than growing their membership base in the new areas of the economy.
Thus, the delivery bikers are not unionised, neither are call centre employees. There are a host of social media platform companies in South Africa, such as Facebook, TikTok and Google, and none of the people working in those companies are unionised.
One of the reasons trade unions began was because of the lack of job security. Without unions, companies were able to easily dismiss workers without fear of a backlash. They could lower wages or not give increases.
Take the time to speak to many of our young people. You will find that many of them are working in call centres, where they are sales persons selling financial products or dental plans to people all over the world. They earn anything from R4?000 to R8??000 a month. They have no job security and remain on probation in the hope of becoming permanent. There are no trade unions organising in this sector.
Uber drivers are not unionised. They are also, like the delivery biker, regarded as “independent contractors”.
It’s not that the businesses in an internet-based economy have outsmarted the trade union leadership, but it does seem that unions care only about their current workers’ membership fees and not about the rest of society.
I first got into social media in about 2009, when I signed up for Facebook. I recall that they had a catchy motto: “It’s free and it always will be”. In 2012, Facebook listed as a public company and its share price rocketed. I kept wondering how Facebook made money, so that people bought these shares and the share price just kept rising. I was wondering whether it was going to be similar to the early 2000s with the dot.com bubble burst. Everyone told me that, like Google, Facebook made money through advertising. I still failed to understand how it became a trillion dollar company; it could not just be with advertising.
In the wake of the election of Donald Trump as the United States’ president in 2016, as well as the 2013 defection of American intelligence officer Edward Snowden to Russia, the movie-documentary Cambridge Analytica was released. This documentary revealed how Facebook (and other social media platforms) could use their algorithm to ensure that many people held a particular view. Facebook, Google and others allow full access to the US government to not only track peoples’ views but to also sculpt and mould them in a particular way. In other words, Facebook and others were weaponised.
I had naively thought Facebook was valuable because it gave pleasure and entertainment to the masses, not because it could be used by the powerful and elite to control the masses. When that realisation hit me, I felt quite foolish.
It gets worse, though. Surveillance Valley is a book by Yashane Levine which was published in 2018. It traces the history and development of the internet. I, and others, could be forgiven for believing that Facebook co-founder Mark Zuckerberg had no choice but to allow his product to be data-mined and therefore weaponised, so that it could be commercially viable. But what Levine proved is that the internet was not weaponised; it was created to be a weapon to control society.
The truth of the matter is that we measure value by how much money and control it can give us over others. There is no appetite to change society, even from trade union leaders and their members. Rather, there seems to be a high level of commitment to the capitalist values of private property ownership, individual freedom to pursue profit and market-driven competition.
The pursuit of these values will be the death of us. The elite and powerful use these values and the lure of individual success to control us.
When trade unions began, they knew that their struggle was not limited to the shop floor, but to include changing the values of society. Today, we witness a tired, antiquated trade union movement with no discernible plan on how to counter the gig-based and techno-feudal global economy.
Trade union leaders need to re-commit to the socialist values of their unions, and especially worker solidarity and power. In South Africa, we need the plethora of trade unions to sit down and unite, despite their ideological and political party affiliations. Globally the working class must unite. Global competition has become a race to the bottom and Africa is winning that race, but other continents will soon start catching up.
Donovan E Williams is a social commentator. @TheSherpaZA on X.
Could Ramaphosa make a refugee deal with Trump fly?:
South African President Cyril Ramaphosa is set to meet US President Donald Trump this week. Having seen what happened with Ukraine’s President Volodymyr Zelenskyy, one thing is clear — fact-checking Trump is not useful.
Trump, in any case, has access to any facts he needs; if he chooses to process them in a creative way, telling him he is wrong is not a winning tactic.
What Ramaphosa really needs to do is present Trump with something he desires. South Africa doesn’t have spare $ 400 million flying palaces to offer, so what do we have?
The whole kerfuffle around the Afrikaners claiming to be “refugees” has taken up a lot of head space. Clearly, there is no genocide going on in South Africa. Anyone who studies the stats or who knows the reality on the ground can tell you that being black and poor makes you by far the most at risk of violent crime. If anyone is at risk because of their identity, it is foreigners.
Many believe that the real issue is South Africa’s 2024 International Court of Justice genocide case against Israel — and this is payback.
But the Trump regime is in an unsustainable position with contradictory foreign policy directions. Trump’s recent trip to the Middle East took in Qatar, the United Arab Emirates and Saudi Arabia — and skipped Israel. None of these countries favours destruction of Gaza and driving all its surviving inhabitants out.
So, what can Ramaphosa offer Trump?
He was a lead negotiator in the talks that ended apartheid. He knows how to frame issues in the language of the other side and to win trust.
South Africa is also uniquely positioned relative to the sides of the Israel-Palestine conflict. We have a vocal Jewish community with strong voices for and against Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu, so he has access to those who know the language of that side.
We also have a diverse Islamic community, members of which have played a direct role in humanitarian aid in Gaza — Gift of the Givers. So, he has access to the language of that side too.
The biggest thing missing in the Israel-Palestine conflict is someone who can talk to both sides and who can help them to find common ground. Whether Ramaphosa can do that is untested but he is more qualified than most. If he could play a significant role in persuading the apartheid regime to give up power, he must have a rare skill.
Would Trump buy this? Maybe. Maybe not. But it is an easier sell than fact-checking him on his definition of “refugees” and “genocide”.
It is certainly a better idea than offering to mediate between Russia and Ukraine, as Ramaphosa has before. Vladimir Putin is not someone who looks for common ground and there is no civil society to stand up to him, even if societal support for his war shifted decisively against him.
In Israel, it is different. Netanyahu’s hold on power is far more tenuous. There are many who believe he wants endless war to put the threat of a criminal trial on hold. Even if Netanyahu himself and his hardline cabinet resist peace efforts, they do not have a unified or cowed society behind them.
What else could Ramaphosa offer?
Clearly the Afrikaners being exported aren’t refugees and refugee advocates are rightly angry that they are being given a free pass when others — particularly Afghans who are at risk for having worked for the US occupation — are being threatened with being sent home. In international law, refugees are defined by the 1951 Refugee Convention as people in imminent danger of being killed or severely injured because of their identity or proximity to war.
A core principle is that no one should be sent back to a country where they face a serious threat to their life or freedom; this principle is called non-refoulement. The convention was adopted in large part in response to the shiploads of Jewish refugees from Nazism who were turned back to their deaths — although work on it started between the two world wars, arising from World War I refugees.
A big misconception about refugees is lumping them in with other migrants. Someone fleeing lack of economic opportunity — even if it is so severe that they risk starvation — is not a refugee, but an economic migrant, and they have no protection under the convention. A large fraction of economic migrants — the majority in some countries — arrive by regular means and overstay their visas.
Another big misconception is that people who arrive by irregular means such as unauthorised border crossings or leaky boats are “queue-jumpers”. There is no orderly queue. People fleeing imminent danger don’t sit at home filling in forms and waiting for a police clearance (as the Afrikaners did). Anyone who has a reasonable claim to be a refugee is an asylum seeker, and is entitled to have their claim evaluated; they should only be sent home if the claim is not valid.
Ramaphosa could offer to take on any of those who have been properly vetted if the US provides reasonable compensation for the costs of rehousing them and integrating them into society. That would put South Africa on the right side of history and absolve the Trump regime of being accused of sending deserving claimants to refugee status home to their deaths.
So, win-win.
Ramaphosa uses his unique skills and positioning to try to find common ground between Israel and Palestine and relieves Trump of refugees he doesn’t want. It’s not as flashy as a flying palace but it could work.
Philip Machanick is an emeritus associate professor of computer science at Rhodes University. https://www.facebook.com/MakanaCitizensFront
Submit and get free exposure here: Showcase Your Business | Advertise Your Special Offers.

