State capture-accused Yakhe Kwinana loses chartered accountant membership:
Former SAA board member Yakhe Kwinana — who the Zondo report said either has no clue about, or dishonestly pretended not to know the obligations of her profession — has lost her membership to the South African Institute of Chartered Accountants (Saica).
Saica announced the immediate withdrawal of Kwinana’s membership on Thursday, a decision taken after a disciplinary hearing. Saica’s disciplinary committee said Kwinana “was not a fit and proper individual to be a member of the profession”, according to a statement.
The institute said in January 2022 that it was investigating Kwinana, at the time of the release of the first 874-page volume of the Zondo state capture commission’s report. Among other allegations, the report noted evidence that the former chartered accountant personally received R4.3 million in payments from a South African Airways Technical (SAAT) supplier.
Kwinana’s disciplinary hearing concluded in March 2023. The disciplinary committee found her guilty of 13 of the 14 charges levied against her. One of the charges was withdrawn.
The committee imposed a R300 000 fine per charge in respect of two charges, and a R500 000 fine per charge for the remaining 11.
Kwinana was accused of acting alongside former SAA board chairperson Dudu Myeni to bring about the beleaguered national carrier’s decline, which ultimately led to it being put under business rescue in 2020.
The Zondo commission recommended that the National Prosecuting Authority consider prosecuting Kwinana for corruption and was scathing about her knowledge of the accounting profession.
“The commission believes that the answers she gave to certain questions during her evidence revealed either that she has no clue about some of the basic obligations that she should know as a chartered accountant or she knew those obligations but dishonestly pretended that she did not know them because it was convenient for her to do so.”
Kwinana’s tenure, the report notes, marked a period of “poor quality and ineffectiveness” at SAA and SAAT.
Kwinana was closely aligned to Myeni, who the commission has also recommended be prosecuted for her role in SAA’s deterioration. The pair “caused sustained damage to our national airline”, the Zondo report stated.
“They bullied officials within SAA who tried to resist their unlawful conduct. They created a climate so intolerable for many personnel that they left the airline or were forced out only to be replaced by more pliant employees.”
The report added that the management style and approach of both Myeni and Kwinana “enabled acts of fraud and corruption to engulf the entities”.
“They became companies in which decision-making was driven by the benefits that would accrue to those in charge as opposed to what was in the companies’ best interests.”
The possible corruption charge against Kwinana stems from evidence that she personally received payments from aviation company JM Aviation, which worked with Swissport SA for five years from April 2016 to provide ground and aviation services to SAAT for R1 billion.
The circumstances of the Swissport transaction were irregular and unlawful, the commission found.
In addition, the report noted, there was a strange black economic empowerment provision included in this contract that ended up benefitting JM Aviation to the tune of R6 million. Shortly after that R6 million came into JM Aviation’s bank account, and was used to benefit Kwinana personally to the amount of R4.3 million, according to the report.
In August 2020, JM Aviation director Vuyisile Ndzeku told the commission that in 2016 he decided to invest some of the money he made at the aviation company in foreign-exchange trading through Zanospark — Kwinana’s company. Ndzeku claimed he did not know the money was going to Kwinana.
Records obtained by the commission show that between July and September 2016, Zanospark received repeated payments from JM Aviation directly or from Ndzeku’s wife. During that period nothing else of any note was happening in the Zanospark bank account, evidence leader advocate Kate Hofmeyr told the commission in August 2020.
According to the report, Zanospark was only created in February 2016 and had an opening balance of R502. Once Kwinana had left SAA, further amounts were paid to her directly from JM Aviation.
The report stated that Kwinana failed to give any plausible explanation for why, as the chairperson of SAAT and a board member of SAA, it was lawful and appropriate for her to have received payments from an entity that was a supplier to SAAT. “The payments were, therefore, probably corrupt payments because they were made in exchange for decisions, in which Ms Kwinana was involved, that benefitted the entity that made the payments.”
According to the Zondo report, it was clear from Kwinana’s evidence that she engaged in extensive forex trading on online platforms. The commission noted that, if Kwinana was legitimately trading on behalf of third parties as her clients, then she would be required to have a licence as a financial services provider.
But during her evidence at the commission, Kwinana persistently denied that she needed a licence to do forex trading. “The fact that Ms Kwinana, a chartered accountant who operated an accounting firm for many years, would not get a licence from the FSCA [Financial Sector Conduct Authority], if she were legitimately investing on behalf of third parties, seems highly unlikely,” the report read.
“The absence of a licence therefore tends to indicate that Ms Kwinana was not conducting forex trading activities for others, but for herself. The manner in which Ms Kwinana dealt with the funds in her account and the Zanospark account also indicates that she treated the money as her own and not as the investment monies of clients.”
The commission added that Kwinana also displayed a fundamental lack of appreciation of conflict of interest policies and processes.
“Instead of knowing and applying these policies and processes, she testified that she preferred her own subjective opinion of her own independence. Independence and avoiding conflicts of interest is one of the cornerstones of corporate governance and public accountability,” the report read.
“It is, therefore, of great concern that a professional chartered accountant would not accept this principle and instead conduct herself while on the boards of SAA and SAAT without proper knowledge of, or adherence to, its requirements.”
Saica chief executive Freeman Nomvalo said in Thursday’s statement that the body “takes all instances of members’ alleged contravention of the Saica Code of Professional Conduct seriously and all these matters are investigated, irrespective of the nature of the assignment or the individual member concerned. Saica deals with all allegations without fear or favour.”
Saica members who fail to uphold the highest ethical and professional standards compromise public and private sector institutions and the South African economy, said Nomvalo.
“This step confirms Saica’s commitment to holding all its members accountable as well as an unwavering focus on serving the public interest, which is the foundation of the chartered accountancy profession,” he added.
No escape for non-believers in deeply-Christian Southern Africa:
After a while, it becomes exhausting to remind people that no, you are not religious, so you go along with the numerous rituals
A flexible, portable solution is at hand for your small business
Most South Africans are fed up with the near constant load-shedding, and are looking for different options. But, does one buy an inverter or a generator? EcoFlow has the answer. Founded in 2017, EcoFlow is a sustainable energy solutions company that has built a strong reputation as a tech-savvy power provider for consumers who need electricity when none is available. EcoFlow has empowered more than two million people in over 100 markets across the globe, and its arrival in the country has come at a time when small and micro businesses need a viable solution. Cue the DELTA 2 and RIVER 2 series.
Bringing power to the people
Brimming with state-of-the-art technology, these power stations are equipped with high-capacity lithium-ion batteries that last 3 000 charge cycles or the equivalent of 10 years of regular use. They are all also capable of achieving a full charge in 80 minutes, thanks to EcoFlow’s patented X-Stream technology. This makes them perfect for entrepreneurs running small businesses that are being severely hit by load-shedding.
One of the key benefits of the EcoFlow DELTA 2 and RIVER 2 series is their portability. These power stations are compact and lightweight — the DELTA 2 weighs 12kg, while the RIVER 2 Max weighs 6.1kg and the RIVER2 weighs a paltry 3.5kg. This makes them easy to transport to different locations as needed. This is especially useful for small businesses that may need to move their operations to different sites during load-shedding.
The DELTA 2, A home office specialist
As EcoFlow’s flagship product on the South African market, the DELTA 2 is a robust energy solution that gives consumers a taste of energy independence. Sporting LiFePO4 batteries and weighing just 12kg, the DELTA 2 has enough capacity to comfortably deal with long power outages and professional work. If you found yourself in stage 8 load-shedding for example, the DELTA 2 could comfortably power your laptop and 12 other devices for multiple consecutive load-shedding blocks. Using the EcoFlow Solar Charge attachments, a full charge can be achieved in as fast as three hours.
The RIVER 2 and RIVER 2 Max: Power anytime, anywhere
For consumers with less onerous backup power needs, the RIVER 2 and RIVER 2 Max are perfect entry points into the world of portable power stations. The RIVER 2 has a capacity of 256Wh, a rated output of 300W (X-boost 600W) and five power outlets. Its larger cousin, the RIVER 2 Max can generate a rated output of 500W (X-boost 1000W) with a capacity of 512W and has nine outlets. Both have a lifespan of 3000 charges beyond 80%, which translates to roughly a decade of use. The RIVER 2 Max, which only weighs 6kg, features a potential full recharge time of under one hour when plugged into an AC wall socket, and EcoFlow power stations can also be recharged by 12V/24V car adapters. Similarly, the lightweight RIVER 2, at 3kg, can also achieve a full charge when plugged into an AC wall socket, but will take just three hours using the Solar Charge attachments.
Overflowing with features
Both the EcoFlow DELTA 2 and RIVER 2 series come with a burnished LCD screen that displays real-time power usage and battery life, making it easy to keep track of your power usage. They are also built to work perfectly in the toughest conditions, including extreme temperatures and rough terrain. Combined with their portability, this means that businesses that do not need fixed premises, and do not need to be rooted to one space the way they would be with an inverter. The DELTA 2 and RIVER 2 series also feature a range of charging options, making them as flexible as the new world of work is.
All EcoFlow products also offer a range of safety features, including surge protection, short circuit protection, and temperature control. This helps protect the power stations and the devices connected to them, ensuring they remain safe and functional, even during periods of high demand.
As a small business owner, being subject to the whims of the power utility’s load-shedding schedule is not a recipe for success. With EcoFlow’s DELTA 2 and RIVER 2 series, you can help safeguard your business and take power back into your own hands.
EcoFlow’s DELTA 2 and RIVER 2 Series ranges are available for purchase from authorised dealers across South Africa and directly from the official website.
Recommended retail prices:
- DELTA 2 – R24 999
- RIVER 2 – R6 999
- RIVER 2 MAX – R12 999
Submit and get free exposure here: Showcase Your Business | Advertise Your Special Offers.
