
Travellers’ tales have the reputation of being tall tales too. In the world before GPS, detailed maps available at the touch of a key on a cellphone and wi-fi almost everywhere, it was so much easier to pretend to be somewhere you were not.
Accusations of simulation and invention have dogged the accounts of great travellers from Herodotus of Halicarnassus to Marco Polo, Ibn Battuta and Hasan al-Wazzan, better known as Leo Africanus.
Perhaps the most extreme form of travel scepticism is the school of thought that claims Apollo XI did not land on the moon but in a fabricated environment created to resemble the lunar landscape.
It’s easier to sympathise with earlier disbelief than with the conspiracy-style argument about lunar exploration. But the need for wry acceptance of stories told by “ancient travellers” has eroded with time because archaeological, historical and anthropological research and discoveries have vindicated, rather than refuted, what for centuries were derided as either implausible or plain, downright lies.
Herodotus, who was born between 490 and 480 BCE and died in 425?BCE, was known both as the Father of History and the Father of Lies.
His marvellous work The Histories combines deep research and inquiry into the causes of the war between Greece and Persia in the fifth century BCE with a lively account of his travels in Egypt, which he visited after 454 BCE, and of its customs, agriculture, culture and history. From there, Herodotus went on to the city of Tyre and then to Babylon, possibly via the Euphrates River.
The unflattering epithet Father of Lies derives largely from passages such as the following, in which he lists the annual tribute in gold the 20 provinces of the Persian Empire paid to their ruler, Darius.
“Twentieth: the Indians, the most populous nation in the known world, paid the largest sum: 360 talents of gold-dust.”
So far, so good for readers, ancient or modern. But soon the eyes fall upon this: “These are the most warlike of the Indian tribes, and it is they who go out to fetch the gold — for in this region there is a sandy desert. There is found in this desert a kind of ant of great size — bigger than a fox, though not so big as a dog. Some specimens, which were caught there, are kept at the palace of the Persian king. These creatures as they burrow underground throw up the sand in heaps, just as ants in Greece throw up the earth, and they are very similar in shape. The sand has a rich content of gold, and this it is that the Indians are after when they make their expeditions into the desert.”
(The quote comes from the classic Herodotus translation by Aubrey de Sélincourt. Readers might also want to try the excellent new version by the superb classicist and historian Tom Holland.)
The story of the gold-digging ants is Herodotus as alert traveller, reporter on the look-out for tales of interest and practical anthropologist millennia before the disciplines of physical and cultural anthropology were born. But, you ask, how can we believe him?
The short answer will direct you to further but briefer reading, the rebuttal of charges against Herodotus for being fantastical and ahistorical that is Stephen Dalley’s article, “Why Did Herodotus Not Mention the Hanging Gardens of Babylon?” It’s to be found in Herodotus and his World: Essays from a Conference in Memory of George Forrest, edited by Peter Derow and Robert Parker (2003).
A similar question of why not was asked by Frances Wood in her book Did Marco Polo Go to China? (1996). Central to the argument here is why Polo makes no mention of the Great Wall of China. Embarrassingly for Wood, at the time head of the Chinese section at the British Library, as well as her editors and publishers, the answer was and is simple: it had not yet been built.
Accusations of Polo inventing it all are not new. Earlier readers and critics pointed out that surely so observant a young man would have had something to say about tea, printing and Chinese calligraphy, to name the most obvious omissions from his book. Those and other popular and specialist quibbles are neatly addressed in Marco Polo: From Venice to Xanadu by Laurence Bergreen (2008).
Blending biography, travel and narrative history, Bergreen gives us an absorbing and engaging book, but nothing is as wonderful and thrilling as the original text itself: Description of the World by Messer Marco Polo.
The book is, of course, better known in English as The Travels or The Travels of Marco Polo, but its original Italian title, Divisement dou Monde, speaks to the ambition and scope of the work. It’s essential to note that Marco did not write the text but dictated it.
The prologue, with its curious style placing Marco in the third person, lets readers know on the very first page: “Let me tell you, then, that to gain this knowledge he stayed in these various countries and territories fully twenty-six years. Afterwards, in the year of the Nativity of Our Lord Jesus Christ 1298, while he was in prison in Genoa, wishing to occupy his leisure as well as to afford entertainment to readers, he caused all these things to be recorded by Messer Rustichello of Pisa, who was in the same prison. But what he told was only what little he was able to remember.” (From the best English translation, RE Latham’s 1958 version for the Penguin Classics.)
What’s this, then? Two jailbirds concocting a non-fiction fraud to perpetrate on an early reading-public? No — Marco was a prisoner of war, captured by the Genoese from the Venetian galley he commanded at the naval Battle of Curzola on 6?September 1298, a disaster for the Republic of Venice.

Rustichello, from Pisa, was similarly a captive of war, at the Battle of Meloria in 1284 when Genoa trounced the Pisan fleet.
More significantly, Rustichello was a renowned writer of Arthurian romances, so much so he attracted the favour of no less a reader than King Edward I of England.
One can see how Marco’s adventures, cast of foreign people, unseen and unimagined lands, strange beasts and awe-inspiring landscapes, and novelty with its sleeping partner horror, would have instantly appealed to Rustichello’s imagination and literary skills.
Here was a young man from a merchant family on a “fabulous” journey requiring enterprise, resourcefulness and endurance, an analogue to Rustichello’s knights going on hazardous and challenging quests.
Marco had been entrusted with missions by the Great Khan, Kublai himself. One of the great writing partnerships was born and it remains fascinating to this day to see where Rustichello embellishes the closely observed recollections of Marco.
There’s a slim and subtle novel that speculatively explores the authorship of The Travels, called Myself and Marco Polo by Paul Griffiths (1989), a delightful exercise that shows postmodernism and “the death of the author” begin rather earlier than devotees of those like to think.
To set the timeline: Marco was born on 15 September 1254 and died on 8 January 1324, 700 years ago this week. His story, full of “tall tales” that have been proved true, is still a marvel today. It shows a young man travelling with his father Niccoló and uncle Maffeo and absorbing all he sees, hears, smells, feels and intuits around him.
And what journeying! A simplified itinerary of his travels looks like this: Venice, Constantinople, Acre, Mosul, Baghdad, Hormuz, Balkh, Khotan, Shang-tu (Xanadu), Cambulac (Beijing; Khan-balik or Cambalu in older forms), much of China (Cathay), Pagan in Burma (Myanmar), Hangzhou, the South China Sea, the Straits of Sumatra, Ceylon (Sri Lanka), the Malabar coast of India, Hormuz, Tabriz, Trebizond, Constantinople, Venice.
Many discoveries await the first-time reader, and what reunions with old friends — human, animal, cultural, spiritual, geographical, topographical, meteorological — for the returning reader.
The prologue begins with a dedication to “all people who wish to know the various races of humankind and peculiarities of the various regions of the world”.
It’s magical, then, to turn to the book’s opening words: “Let me begin with Armenia. The truth is that there are actually two Armenias, a Greater and a Lesser.”
Tongaat Hulett business rescue on, but sugar industry concerned over R900m in unpaid levies:

The South African sugar industry has cautiously welcomed the sale of Tongaat Hulett Limited to the Vision Partners consortium this week, which prevented the more than a century old company from going into liquidation.
But the sugar industry is concerned over the commitment of Vision Partners – led by ANC funder Robert Gumede’s Guma group – to paying more than R900 million in sugar industry levies which Tongaat Hulett owes.
Last week Tongaat’s creditors meeting voted in favour of a business rescue plan submitted by Vision Partners, which is made up of Guma Agri & Food Security Group, Zimbabwe’s Remogogoo Investments, the Terris Fund and Pakistani sugar giant Almoiz.
They did so after the withdrawal of competing bidder RGS Sugar, who claimed in a letter to business rescue practitioners that the process had been rigged in favour of Vision, and that they feared that their bid would be undermined even if they were to succeed.
Vision purchased around R8 billion in secured debt held by a group of banks ahead of the vote for an undisclosed amount, giving them control of the voting process, in which their bid received unanimous support.
The agreement ends a length and heavily contested process which ended up in the court several occasions and which only went ahead after the withdrawal of a threat to interdict the process by RCL Foods, which owns Selati Sugar, over the unpaid levies.
At the weekend, SA Canegrowers chairperson Andrew Russell said that while they noted the vote by creditors, they remained concerned over the unpaid levies and Vision’s commitment to pay them.
“While the vote marks a critical step forward in the effort to save Tongaat Hulett, SA Canegrowers awaits confirmation by the Vision Group of its commitment to pay the industry levies owed to the South African Sugar Association by Tongaat Hulett,” he said.
“The Vision Group has yet to commit to payment of the outstanding levies before any appeals of the declarator order have been exhausted, leaving open the possibility of further costly and time-consuming litigation,” Russel said.
Both SA Canegrowers and the South African Sugar Association (SASA) had gone to court to force both Vision and RGS to incorporate the payment of the industry levies into their business rescue plans.
This after the High Court ruled that the business rescue process had to accommodate payment of the levies, which were part of the cost of doing business in the industry.
The levies subsidise growers who provide sugar cane to Tongaat for milling and ensure that there is profitability all the way along the sugar value chain through payments to growers via SASA.
The company had defaulted on payment for nearly a year and only started paying again earlier this year after SASA and SA Canegrowers went to court.
Tongaat, South Africa’s leading sugar producer, lost around R12 billion in value and was delisted from the JSE due to an alleged R3.5 billion accounting fraud by former chief executive Peter Staude and a group of managers and accounts.
They allegedly inflated profits of its now defunct property division in order to secure profit shares and productivity bonuses and were found out in 2019.
The business rescue process has hit Tongaat’s suppliers – including an estimated 25 000 small scale sugar farmers who supply it with cane – hard.
Russell said that when Tongaat went into business rescue in October 2022, this had left the industry in a precarious state and had caused “great uncertainty” for growers who relied on its KwaZulu-Natal north coast.
These hardships had been exacerbated by the court action by Metis and Tongaat Hulett.
Russell said the withdrawal of RGS was “a further blow” as the company had undertaken to honour Tongaat’s industry obligations in their business rescue plan.
Despite this, the organisation was “encouraged” by the success of the BRPs in securing a partner to save Tongaat’s mills as tens of thousands of small growers depended on them.
Vision spokesperson Rob Bessinger declined to talk to the Mail & Guardian, saying he would do so at the appropriate time, but said in a statement that the consortium was “particularly elated” and “grateful” at the success of the vote.
“Having been involved in this transaction since late 2020, we always believed that in the right hands, THL can return to be a great business. We have a team that has a sustainable plan to turnaround, grow and diversify the group back into relevance,” he said.
He said Vision would “engage and settle with SASA” in line with the court judgement and would engage with the Industrial Development Corporation (IDC) regarding its post commencement funding “ on win-win terms to be agreed by all parties and in the best interests of the company and the sector.”
Metis said in a statement that the adoption of the rescue plan ‘finally provides some certainty to stakeholders on the way forward.’
They would now proceed with the implementation of the plan, which would have to be “substantially implemented” – or be no longer financially distressed – before the company could exit business rescue.
This would take “several months”, Metis said.
SASA has welcomed the adoption of the rescue plan as averted liquidation and paved the way for the recovery of Tongaat Hullett.
“We are pleased that the business rescue process has produced a positive result. All Industry stakeholders including the government have been fully committed to saving Tongaat Hulett since the commencement of the business rescue process,” SASA chairperson Fay Mukkadam said.
Mukkadam said SASA looked forward to working with the new owners to ensure that the rescue plan was successfully implemented.
Tongaat’s unsecured creditors – many of them small local businesses – are happy to have avoided liquidations, but have come out of the process worst.
They are now getting far less than the 65 cents on the Rand which they would have, should the RGS bid have not been withdrawn and succeeded.
One unsecured creditor, who has been owed just under R10 million since 2021 and who asked not to be named, said they believed the process could have been handled far better.
“We are pleased that liquidation has been avoided and that for now jobs at THS and amongst the cane growing community have been saved,’ the creditor said.
“But we are very disappointed at the outcome for the unsecured creditors – mostly small companies like ours. The BRPs have always described business rescue as a creditor driven process, but in reality we have had absolutely no say in the outcome at all, as overwhelming voting power rests with the lender group,” the creditor said.
“The order of precedence in liquidation and in business rescue seems heavily skewed in favour of the banks – who should surely have more financial expertise than us and should have conducted better “due diligence” before advancing the money,” they said.
They shared the view of RGS that the process had been manipulated to favour the Vision group.
“We can only agree with the comments in the RGS letter to the BRPs reported in the media, that the BRPs appear to have bent over backwards to accommodate the Vision group, when on the face of it the RGS plan seemed better in every respect,” they said.
“Under the RGS plan, we would have received around 65 cents on the rand. As it is, we will only receive a tiny fraction of what we are owed, which is a devastating loss for a small organisation like ours,’ the creditor said.
“The BRPs have commented that a few cents on the rand is better than getting nil under liquidation, but this appears hypocritical considering that according to the order of precedence, their fees get paid before anyone else gets a look in.”
Metis this week denied the claims made by RGS in their letter, saying they were “baseless” and said that they would respond in due course.
Russell said they would “ closely follow developments in the coming weeks as the business rescue process hopefully nears its end point. “
“Our priority remains the successful conclusion of the business rescue process that revives Tongaat Hulett and protects the livelihoods that depend on its operations,” Russell said.
Submit and get free exposure here: Showcase Your Business | Advertise Your Special Offers.

