Thabo Bester’s escape shows how privatising harms crime control:
Thabo Bester escaped from his prison cell — by faking his death in the form of a mysterious burnt corpse specially brought in for the purpose — in the privately-run Mangaung maximum security prison in Bloemfontein in May last year. Although Bester has been returned to the country, it raises interesting questions about the negative effect of globalisation on the domestic management of crime.
From a criminological perspective, it also interrogates the extent to which the uncritical importation of penal hardware (such as the privatisation of prisons) from the centre (developed countries) to the periphery (the Third World), is advisable.
To illustrate, I am of the view that the rationale for the privatisation drive regarding prisons, not only in this country, but worldwide, is closely linked to two global developments. The first is a growing international trend to punitively manage so-called “surplus populations” of the unemployed, homeless and hopeless by way of incarceration, which has succeeded in locking in the profit motive.
Robert Weiss, a comparative criminologist, argued presciently almost 25 years ago that, “Declining liberality and growing intolerance is [sic] unmistakably the most outstanding feature of world penal systems and this repressive policy derives from a common overarching reality: prisons throughout the world are expected to manage a rapidly increasing ‘surplus population’.”
The second trend concerns how these “surplus populations” are managed. This is done by way of an American animal known as the “prison-industrial complex” (abbreviated to PIC) and is another feasible reason for both prison expansion and privatisation. This PIC is crisply defined as prison expansion for monetary gain without any actual need.
While a person with the political stature of Raymond Suttner argues, with reference to Bester’s escape, that “state institutions […] concerned with public security, are eroding, collapsing and generally dysfunctional. The media conferences that officials have held after these events have reinforced the view of incompetence, but also a complete lack of connection with the sentiments and fears that people legitimately have about this escape.”
Suttner’s point is well conceived, but at the tail end of late capitalism, I would suggest that the government’s incompetence is tied in, at least in part, with its complicity to the agenda of Big Business. Note, for example, that G4S’s (a multinational company managing prisons all over the world) 25-year contract to run Mangaung was entered into in 2000. Even though it was meant to expire in 2026, the department of correctional services has now retaken control of the prison.
This date (2000, the date for the signing of G4S’s contract) would mean that my previous calculations on the timing of the emergence of the PIC in South Africa was wrong. In a scholarly paper, following up on a clue provided by the famous prison abolitionist, Angela Davis, I suggested that the date was May 2002 “[i]f we assume that the first documented evidence of the presence of PIC on South African soil appeared […] with the inauguration of the Ebongweni-supermax prison in Kokstad”. This phenomenon “has indeed skewed the picture of crime and re-offending” and managed to get a foothold in South Africa.
The Bester breakout also beautifully illustrates the fact that most powerful criminals, such as Bester (and the Guptas?), are simply beyond the reach of criminal law. Consider, for example, the government-backed cybercriminals entrenched in countries such as North Korea, Russia, China and especially the US. Only a carefully tailored security culture embedded in corporations in general can prevent the devastation of cyberattacks, because there is little hope of successfully prosecuting transnational crime of this sort.
Bester and his girlfriend were arrested in Tanzania over the Easter weekend and their testimony in South Africa is eagerly awaited. However, as the debacles regarding the extraditions for the Bushiri couple (from Malawi) and the Gupta brothers (from the United Arab Emirates) show, the management of these requests have not inspired a great deal of trust in the South African government’s ability to deliver on justice for powerful criminals.
An infamous example of the latter is this country (notably KwaZulu-Natal and Gauteng) going up in flames after (an opportunistic) Msholozi’s arrest following the constitutional court’s ruling which sentenced former president Jacob Zuma to a short spell of incarceration for contempt of court.
In South Africa, prison privatisation is not a growing trend, although the practice of making money from punishment has grown in other ways. The two private prisons in South Africa, Mangaung in Bloemfontein and Kutama Sinthumule in Louis Trichardt, Limpopo, cost the South African government an eye-watering R1 billion a year.
In a piece for The Conversation, I asked investigative journalist Ruth Hopkins, author of the book The Misery Merchants (2020), for her take on the private company that ran Mangaung maximum security prison in relation to Bester’s escape. She confirmed that the so-called “EST (Emergency Security Team), known as the Ninjas, used their electrified shields as a torture instrument and regularly electroshocked prisoners for minor transgressions, such as complaining about the quality of food or the lack of blankets”, and that “the number of suspicious deaths in Mangaung prison” were extremely concerning issues.
For context, it appears plausible that the phenomenon of the privatisation of prisons in South Africa, in particular, even though happening globally, is a relic of state capture during the Zuma-years. What comes to mind, in a corollary fashion, is the Bosasa-correctional services tender and supply-chain scandal, which lasted for at least a decade, even after the Special Investigating Unit brought out a damning report in 2009 against Bosasa’s allegedly corrupt dealings with the department.
One is tempted to ask, as did Davis, whether this money could not have been spent in a better way to allow people to live healthier, more constructive lives, instead. Road maintenance, better healthcare, education and job creation are all feasible alternatives to spending money on incarceration, especially in the context of the PIC. Davis is the author of Are Prisons Obsolete? (2003), which is freely available on the internet as an audiobook.
The public would be well within their rights to question the issue of prison expansion when the motive driving such commercial incentives is not primarily public safety but rather the deep pockets of government officials — the Bosasa and Bester cases are good examples. This includes the dubious agendas of Big Business with whom these government officials are in cahoots.
We should also be vigilant about the government’s tendency to solve social problems (homelessness, unemployment) by way of incarceration, which should not be entertained.
Motsoaledi tore up policy paper in scrapping Zimbabwe exemption permit, court hears:
The Helen Suzman Foundation argued in court this week that the home affairs minister mislead permit holders and failed to give them a fair chance to regularise their status
Lindiwe Hani: ‘Realising dreams is a gift to my father’:
I am the youngest (and, like to believe, favourite) daughter of the late Chris Hani, the prominent leader of the ANC and the South African Communist Party (SACP). His main objective was the liberation of black people in South Africa and equality across all races.
By the time I was born, during the height of apartheid in the early 1980s, our family was already living separately. My mother and sisters and I were living in Lesotho, and my father was based all over the world.
We would get to visit him once a year, typically in Zambia, and that was the only time in my childhood that we could be together as a family.
To say that I treasured those three months a year would be an understatement. I completely adored my father. I think that due to the separation, he became more than my father and played the role of superhero.
I was told that the reason we were not together as a family was that my father was making the world a better place. The same way that my father was a leader, the same way he led soldiers, was the way he was a parent.
He was always available, kind and practical — whether you were his annoying daughter complaining about her mother or a head of state, his attention on you was on par. I am yet to meet anyone who knew my father and didn’t feel that from him.
My childhood was pretty idyllic, considering we lived under constant threat from the apartheid regime.
We would often have to leave our home and rely on the kindness of the community or family to house us. We would have to watch my mother every morning look under the hood of the car to check for bombs. In between what I have come to recognise was not a normal upbringing, we were surrounded by love.
The choice my parents made to raise us in Lesotho, as opposed to following my father around the world, gave us some form of stability and security.
When the political parties were unbanned in 1990, it was an incredibly joyous time for our family. It meant we lived as a family for the first time, at least in my lifetime.
We had about a year and a half of our family being whole and then the unimaginable happened.
Daddy was assassinated in our driveway on 10 April 1993. From the moment that Janusz Walus pulled that trigger and gunned my father down like an animal, that one bullet became the catalyst for the destruction of my family — and almost my own destruction.
I may or may not have made the decision to become immersed in a world of addiction due to my father’s death — all I know is that I did not have the tools to deal with this overwhelming loss.
Not only did I have to deal with the loss of my father privately, but I had to mourn publicly, and I was also instructed to demonstrate strength to the South African people. Not the best advice for a 12-year-old.
I became addicted to drugs at the age of 17 until I made the decision to get help and go into rehab in 2014.
My instinct is to explain and justify what kind of an addict I was as if that will somehow make a difference. The only explanation is that I was in such utter pain and despair, escapism felt like my only solution.
Becoming a parent and believing there has to be more to life than trauma and devastation is what led me to walk into the rehab centre.
I needed to make sure my daughter had a fighting chance besides inherited trauma. The only option I had was death or healing. I chose the latter and have been better off since.
When I was asked to speak publicly about the legacy of anti-apartheid activist Hugh Lewin and my father, Chris Hani, I felt apprehension and fear. These were men who put every-thing, including their own lives, on hold. They disregarded their own safety and needs, and that of their families, to fight for the injustices they experienced in our country.
Who am I? I am the recipient of their sacrifice. We all are.
Being part of this legacy brings its own pressure and even feelings of inadequacy.
Part of my personal struggle was fighting against the legacy of being Chris Hani’s daughter, the fear I will never be good enough to fill his shoes. As a result, I believed that not trying was better than failing. I still battle with the question of what I, as a recovering addict, can impart.
My father lived in a time when there was a collective sense of wrong and right; a time when the basis of humanity was front and centre.
We live in a time that is different. Yes, we see injustices every day. We experience deficiencies in our government and, as a result, our greater society. However, what has changed is the collective sense of good.
We live in a world where we see our leaders personally benefiting richly off the backs of the poor. We are now part of a world where being self-serving — and narcissistic — is celebrated. We are in a world which has lost the most basic quality of humanity — kindness.
I have ambivalence about a day such as Human Rights Day. It is seen as a public holiday where we can all take time off. When I reflect on the day, it brings immense feelings of pain. It is, to be very clear, Sharpeville Day, when a multitude of people were murdered for standing up for their rights — of moving freely without having to prove they belong in their own country.
I am not a politician, and I am not here to give a clear directive of what must be done. Even at my age, I am still exploring how I can make a difference and perhaps leave an indelible mark on our world. The fight the youth of today have ahead of them is not the same fight faced by Hugh Lewin or Chris Hani, but there is definitely a fight ahead.
These are the lessons I have learned. I am Chris Hani’s daughter. It has taken me more than eight years to also acknowledge that I am Lindiwe. In as much as there was difficulty and trauma in my life, having my surname means I am part of a world of privilege.
For those of us in a position of privilege, we have a responsibility to fight the stereotype of how the world may see us and fight for the world to see us as we are. Not as the progeny of your individual lineage, but as the hope of what you will offer the world.
My trauma has been a passenger on my journey, mostly a very unwelcome guest. I used it to fuel my destruction, and when I decided I needed help, it was difficult to let go of my trauma — mainly because I didn’t have an excuse for not being able to deal with life on life’s terms.
I had to face the fact that I had become a horrible human being under the influence and that I had alienated my friends and my family.
I believe that as much as we may not all look to substances to soothe pain/anxiety/fear, holding these emotions in and not speaking out is how we struggle. Please hear me when I say — one doesn’t have to be on this journey alone.
A large part of the rights my father died for, was the right for the youth to make healthier decisions. In our lifetime, we must endeavour for progress and not perfection. We can only begin to improve society and contribute towards our world by beginning with self. Self-healing is not self-serving or narcissism — it is the antidote. We cannot be effective humans while we are struggling and holding on to all kinds of pain and difficulty.
We can reflect on the lives of those who came before us, and look at their lives from the perspective of inspiration and not sorrow — that is not how they would want to be remembered.
As much as my father’s life was as impactful as his death, I had to learn that his death must not bury me. His life is where I must draw strength. When we make strides towards living a robust and full life that boosts those around us, they are smiling.
The scariest and most daunting fight is to be who you are, to fight for at least the discovery of who you are. You will uncover the men and women, leaders, friends and someday parents you are meant to be.
As a nation, we have lost a lot, but we have also gained so much. We have gained the legacies of Hugh Lewin, Chris Hani, Steve Biko, Solomon Mahlangu, Oliver Tambo, Joe Slovo and countless others. We stand on the shoulders of these giants so that we realise not only their dreams but also our own.
This is an edited extract of Lindiwe Hani’s address to St John’s College at the 25th annual Hugh Lewin Memorial Human Rights Day Lecture. Together with Melinda Ferguson, Hani wrote Being Chris Hani’s Daughter (MF Books Joburg).
The views expressed are those of the author and do not necessarily reflect the official policy or position of the Mail & Guardian.
Submit and get free exposure here: Showcase Your Business | Advertise Your Special Offers.

