To carry the ivory spectre or not? Queen Camilla’s predicament:
As King Charles III’s 6 May coronation draws closer, Southern African communities have joined Botswana Chieftainess Rebecca Banika and US-based ivory specialist Godfrey Harris in supporting Buckingham Palace’s decision for Queen Camilla to carry a historic ivory sceptre during the ceremony.
Banika and Harris denounced anti-ivory groups as being “out-of-touch with the undeniable fact that ivory has historical and cultural importance to the world — and a central place in the coronation of a British royal couple”.
“We find the demand by the animal rights groups that Queen Camilla should not use a historic ivory rod totally unreasonable,” said the chairperson of the Southern Africa Community Leaders Network (CLN), Rodgers Lubilo, who was educated at a wildlife-revenue-built secondary school in South Luangwa, Zambia.
“Our own chiefs use ivory and other animal parts such as tails and skins as symbols of the greatness and richness of African culture and their role in preserving it.”
In an interview, Harris, the managing director of the Los Angeles-based Ivory Education Institute, who was born in England and later migrated to the US, said: “I hope everyone watches the coronation to see for themselves whether Charles and Camilla honour 250 years of royal history and she carries the royal sceptre as a symbol of her office as queen consort.”
He added, “Many art connoisseurs, antique experts and cultural historians were upset when a little-known vegan group demanded that the sceptre be left out of the coronation ceremony in order to ‘protect’ elephants in Africa’s range states. They are thankful that King Charles III, Queen Camilla and the royal household have rejected their publicity-seeking plea.”
In an article published last week in the British newspaper, The Telegraph, Cape Town-based journalist Ben Farmer wrote, “Buckingham Palace has defended the use of the three-foot long rod, which represents the Holy Spirit, saying it was inevitable that a large historic collection like the Crown Jewels would contain ivory.”
Farmer continued: “The sceptre was made by the royal goldsmith Sir Robert Vyner for Mary of Modena when she was crowned alongside her husband, James II, in 1685 and has been used to crown every queen consort since.”
Harris, who manages the Ivory Education Institute, has just been given the Best of Brentwood Award for Public Service in 2023.
In acknowledging the importance of the award, Harris commented that the clueless, single-minded anti-ivory “crowd” would disdain the symbolism of history during the coronation “to try to make a hollow political point.” He added that famed Jamaican activist, Marcus Garvey, got it exactly right when he wrote, “People without the knowledge of their past history, origin and culture is like a tree without roots”.
Reacting to an article published in The Daily Mail last week, explaining Banika’s strong support for Queen Camilla’s decision to carry the ivory rod, some of the British paper’s readers supported Camilla’s position while others opposed it.
“There is no reason not to use a beautiful piece made of ivory,” said Clarity, A, of Richmond. “The elephant that provided it has been dead for centuries. You can’t bring it back and give the tusk back to the elephant. It would be wasteful not to use it.”
One of the protestors, Chooselovenothate of Manchester said that to parade through the streets adorned in the dead tusks of murdered elephants takes a certain kind of person to be okay with that.
Elsewhere, a resident of Botswana’s wildlife-rich Ngamiland District and also the director the Ngamiland’s Council of NGOs, Siyoka Simasiku, said that the animal rights groups were concerned that Queen Camilla’s holding an ivory rod at King Charles III’s coronation would signal support of ivory use and trade.
“In SADC countries, the ivory of elephants that die of natural causes is a symbol and source of our community’s livelihood. The anti-ivory groups are afraid that this will communicate the wrong signal [such as the use of wildlife hunting trophies] at a time when the House of Lords is set to review the British parliamentarians’ vote to ban the import of hunting trophies,” said Simasiku.
Lubilo said that the CLN favours the import of hunting trophies just as it “views the animals rights groups’ lobby to pressure Queen Camilla into refusing to carry the ivory rod as hard evidence that they are totally out-of-touch with the reality that ivory is a vital economic resource with important historical as well as cultural value”.
He noted that for many years the animal rights groups have influenced the member countries of CITES, the UN agency that regulates international trade in endangered fauna and flora species. These groups influence the majority of CITES members to vote against proposals from elephant-overpopulated countries to trade in large quantities of stockpiled ivory, unlocking the value of their wildlife through legal and sustainable ivory trade.
“The animal rights groups’ protest against Queen Camilla’s carrying of the ivory rod is unacceptable and should be dismissed with the contempt it deserves,” said Lubilo.
“We wish King Charles III well, during his coronation and coming reign and we look forward to having a conversation in the future with the royal family regarding the workable conservation of all wild species.”
Emmanuel Koro is a Johannesburg-based international award-winning environmental journalist who writes independently on environmental and developmental issues in Africa.
The views expressed are those of the author and do not necessarily reflect the official policy or position of the Mail & Guardian.
We are forced to buy water, say Mpumalanga villagers:
Some households in Zakheni Village, near KwaMhlanga, in Mpumalanga, say they have been without consistent running water for three years. Some are spending hundreds of rand buying water while the Thembisile Hani Local Municipality battles to find a permanent solution.
Zakheni Village was established in 2004 and has a population of 22 140 people, according to municipality spokesperson Simphiwe Mashiyane.
Mashiyane acknowledged water supply disruptions to high-lying areas, which include Zakheni. She said the problem was exacerbated when torrential rains in December last year washed away the bulk water pipeline that supplied water to the community.
The municipality says it sends water tankers to several areas as a short-term solution but some residents say the supply is irregular.
Vusi Skhosana said he and other residents who can afford it buy drinking water from vendors who charge up to R300 to fill a 5 000 litre tank. Most households in the community are poor and don’t have large tanks or containers to store water.
“This tank is not enough for my family as it runs out before the end of every month. We use this water for drinking, cooking and washing clothes,” Skhosana said.
He said that since 2018, they have only had running water in their homes twice a week and then often only for two to three hours at a time.
Skhosana runs a carwash with his business partner William Masilela. They have to wash customers’ cars with water they collect in buckets from a river about 700m away. Masilela said that many people fetch water at the river to use for watering gardens and building houses.
He pointed out that other communities, such as Phola Park, which is about half a kilometre from Zakheni, have running water.
Another resident, Thabiso Mahlangu, said the municipality’s water truck does come to Zakheni but there is not enough water for everyone. People normally collect drinking water from residents of Phola Park, he said. “I’m unemployed and cannot spend R300 on water every month.”
Mashiyane said the municipality had been rationing water for years, with each village getting water once or twice a week.
She said interruptions of supply were more frequent in high-lying areas.
Asked about plans to fix the problem, she said the municipality was working on short and long-term measures with “other stakeholders”, including the Department of Water and Sanitation.
This story was originally published by GroundUp.
Zim firebrand opposition MP convicted, unable to contest in upcoming elections:
A popular opposition politician in Zimbabwe was convicted of obstruction of justice in a high-profile trial this week, a move that bars him from contesting upcoming elections.
In a case that critics said was politically motivated, Job Sikhala was found guilty by a Harare court almost a year after he was first arrested, and after spending more than 300 days behind bars pending the verdict.
“The state has proved its case beyond any reasonable doubt,” magistrate Marewanazvo Gofa told the court on Wednesday. “The accused has no defence at all and is hereby found guilty and convicted of the offence.”
Later in the day, Sikhala was handed a six-month suspended sentence and a $ 600 fine, or another six months behind bars if he fails to pay. He will however remain in jail pending other cases against him.
Charges against Sikhala were based on a video in which he allegedly demanded justice for the murder of another opposition activist whose mutilated body was found in a well.
Prosecutors alleged that by blaming the ruling Zanu-PF party for the death he diverted investigations that were focusing on other suspects.
The charge is one of several facing the 50-year-old firebrand. He is accused in other cases of inciting public violence over the same video and of publishing falsehoods. Judges are still to reach a verdict in those cases.
Sikhala, who was practising as a lawyer before his arrest, has been held in a maximum-security prison in the capital Harare since June 2022 and unsuccessfully applied for bail 15 times.
The conviction is the first in his long and troubled political career, which includes 67 arrests, according to one of his lawyers. The verdict means Sikhala will be unable to contest presidential and legislative elections which are to be held in August, although no date has been announced yet.
“This is a clear travesty of justice,” Gift Ostallos Siziba, a spokesman for Sikhala’s Citizens Coalition for Change party, told reporters outside the court, linking the ruling to the upcoming vote. Critics have accused the government of using the courts to prevent some opposition politicians from running.
“Most of our leaders are in and out of the courts for different concocted political charges,” said Siziba.
Jacob Ngarivhume, leader of a small opposition party, was last week jailed for four years for inciting public violence, a sentence he said was a way to keep him from participating in the next election.
Rights groups and opposition parties have complained of an escalating clampdown ahead of the vote.
President Emmerson Mnangagwa is struggling to ease entrenched poverty, end chronic power cuts and rein in inflation.
Because of his outspoken activism, Sikhala was nicknamed “Wiwa” during his university years after Nigerian environmental activist Ken Saro-Wiwa, who was hanged along with eight Ogoni activists in 1995 on a trumped-up murder charge. – Agence France-Presse
Submit and get free exposure here: Showcase Your Business | Advertise Your Special Offers.

