White Paper on immigration fails Africa’s free trade aspirations:
Arguably no issue gets countries riled up more than immigration. Most of the threats to the global order over the past decade or so have been the emergence of leaders who endorse a sort of protectionism and “securing the borders”.
Immigration is a hot topic in the world and on the African continent, because it is inextricably linked to other aspects of the current economic era, such as globalisation, multiculturalism and diversity.
The Protocol to the Agreement Establishing the African Continental Free Trade Area (AFCFTA) on Investment is very clear about its stance on immigration. Article 7 (2) stipulates that state parties must “facilitate the granting of visas and permits to foreign workers, employees and consultants as designated by the investor”. As a signatory to the AfCFTA, South Africa is also bound to implement this requirement.
If South Africa is intent on fulfilling the provisions of the AfCFTA, then the department of home affairs must relax, rather than retract, its visa requirements for people from other countries, particularly African countries.
White Paper chills immigration prospects
The department has been tinkering with changing the immigration policy of South Africa over the past two years. A White Paper on Citizenship, Immigration and Refugee Protection was tabled in late 2023 for public comments. In it, the department presented a case of South Africa requiring tighter border controls, as well as more stringent requirements for acquiring visas and permits.
The White Paper did not please everybody, and many civil society organisations were not happy with the contents of the paper. They have a point.
South Africa does not need to make it harder for people to live in the country. In fact, the opposite is true: South Africa needs to make it easier for people — especially those from other African countries — to live in the country.
Critical skills
The department’s White Paper stipulates that visas will be primarily given to immigrants who can address the occupations on the critical skills list. For instance, we do not have enough geologists, according to the list. If trained geologists from Rwanda want to work in South Africa, they are more likely to get the critical skills visa, because they address a gap in the market.
This sounds feasible, but the situation is not that simple.
We need to ask questions about the reliability of the critical skills list, and whether this is the best way to evaluate who enters the country, and who does not.
Governments are terrible at being at the forefront of anything, much less workforce trends across multiple industries. The structure of government makes it difficult for it to determine trends and act on them timeously. How often does the critical skills list get updated? If it is updated fairly consistently, can the department compile the information in a relatively short period to constantly update the list? Is the backlog at the department something to take into account?
All of these questions lead to an important conclusion: the department (or any other department, for that matter) will inevitably fail in upholding stringent immigration policies.
If this is the department’s solution to the immigration crisis, then we are unlikely to see any real change. The critical skills list is attempting to solve the symptom (unskilled immigrants coming to the country seeking better opportunities) and not the disease (the government ratifying the AfCFTA while not adhering to the spirit of the agreement).
The AfCFTA is not radical; it seeks to have African countries trade goods and services with one another. The AfCFTA is radical, because it seeks to encourage cooperation of all kinds between African countries. This kind of cooperation should also include us being able to freely move throughout the continent, no visa needed.
Free trade and free movement
Some may conflate “relaxing visa regulations” with an open border policy. That is not the case. Instead, relaxing visa regulations with trade partners means taking a page from the European Union playbook — free movement for African Union member states. It stands to reason that AfCFTA was conceptualised, in part, to create stronger links between African countries. Why must free movement on the African continent be limited to goods and services?
Not only would this be beneficial to other African countries — because South Africans travel to their destination cities, boosting their tourism prospects — but South Africa would also benefit from a tourist boom. Free trade should go hand in hand with free movement, not least of all because the latter may improve the former.
Research that is most relevant to the provisions of the AfCFTA Protocol on Investment shows that immigrants can boost trade from their home country to the country in which they reside. Immigrants know their home country’s language, regulations, market opportunities and informal institutions. They can use this information to help negotiate trade deals that benefit the country in which they now stay.
As a relatively influential country in the continent, South Africa is in a unique position to radically alter Africa’s prospects for the better. All the country has to do is to resist the temptation of protectionism and isolation. It is only by heeding the call of the AfCFTA Protocol on Investment, and relaxing immigration policies for other African countries, that South Africa can reap the rewards of a united Africa.
Wiseman Zondi is a writer and analyst. He is a 2022 Rhodes Scholar with an MSc in Comparative Social Policy from the University of Oxford. He is a regular contributor for the African Free Trade and Defence Society. The views of the author are not necessarily those of the society.
‘My suspension is not justified,’ MEC Mandla Msibi tells Mpumalanga premier:
Mpumalanga’s cooperative governance and traditional affairs MEC, Mandla Msibi, has told Premier Refilwe Mtsweni-Tsipane that he was “not convinced” his special leave from office was based on his performance and thus cannot be justified.
The decision came two weeks after ANC provincial secretary Muzi Chirwa announced that the party had suspended Msibi, then the party’s provincial treasurer, for three years, two years of which have been lifted on condition he does not commit the same offence.
In a letter to Mtsweni-Tsipane, signed by Msibi and dated 18 April, he said he was busy with provincial projects, and therefore should not be placed on special leave.
He also said: “I am not convinced that the special leave is based on my performance as the MEC and that of the department, and therefore cannot be justified.”
The party took action after Msibi participated in protests around Pienaar, demanding an audience with Cyril Ramaphosa before the president’s 8 January statement in Mpumalanga this year. Msibi is also appealing the suspension.
This is the second time that Msibi has been in trouble with the ANC. He was forced to step aside in 2021 after the National Prosecuting Authority (NPA) charged him with two murders. The NPA withdrew the charges in 2022.
Msibi would not comment on the letter.
In his letter, Msibi told Mtsweni-Tsipane that he, his department and municipalities were still “evaluating and monitoring” “critical water shortages brought about by infrastructure collapse especially in eMalahleni and Msukaligwa”.
“As you may be aware, I have recently directed use of water trucks and other alternative arrangements as I’m currently seized with trying to stabilise the pressing situation in those municipalities,” reads the letter.
Msibi added that he should not be suspended because he was involved with “crucial matters” concerning the grievances of amakhosi in the province. The matters had previously been raised with Deputy President Paul Mashatile, he said.
It would thus not be prudent that he be placed on special leave, he said, “when a lot still needs to be addressed and finalised for both local governments and traditional leaders”.
“I therefore wish to respectfully advise against a special leave during this pressing period and rather concentrate on serving our people in the province as a responsible government.”
Mtsweni-Tsipane’s office did not respond to numerous requests for comment.
Home Affairs opens office in Durban shopping mall:
Home Affairs Minister Aaron Motsoaledi opened the department’s first office at a super mall in KwaZulu-Natal, the Pavilion Shopping Centre in Durban, on Monday.
Motsoaledi said the new office, the third to open at a mall, had been preceded by the opening of branches at Menlyn Park in Pretoria and Cresta Mall in Johannesburg over the past two weeks.
Motsoaledi said the Pavilion office, which had a soft opening to the public on 12 April, had already processed 238 identity documents and 142 passport applications.
“Some of the documents are already here to be handed over to their owners,” he said.
“Many people may have forgotten that a while ago it used to take six months to receive your ID and three months for a passport and I can assure you now we have cut those waiting times to 13 days,” he said. “Of course, there are exceptions here and there where people find problems and these are the exceptions that find their way into the media.
“While our standard is 13 days, we can produce a passport in 24 hours. We do it when we understand your circumstances,” he said.
Motsoaledi said the government hoped the owner of The Pavilion, Pareto Limited, would open doors for additional home affairs offices at other retail properties such as Westgate Shopping Centre and Sandton City in Johannesburg and Mimosa Mall in Bloemfontein.
He said additional branches scheduled to open over the next two weeks included those in Tyger Valley in Cape Town and Southgate in Johannesburg.
“We are no longer going to rely on traditional home affairs office services,” he said. “We are expanding into the malls and we are expanding into the banks and you are no longer having to queue in home affairs offices,” he said.
He said the department offers its services at 29 bank branches countrywide, and is in the process of signing up additional branches. It is also opening home affairs offices in hospitals, preferably near labour wards, to ensure every citizen is documented at birth.
“On this continent we still have people who are born, get married and die without having any record of them ever having been on this planet, and other countries call it the ‘scandal of invisibility’,” he said.
He said Egypt, with 98% of its population documented, was leading the pack on the continent followed by South Africa, which has an 89% documentation rate, meaning 11% of people remain invisible.
“We are fulfilling a promise we gave to parliament that we are expanding into malls, banks and hospitals,” he said.
He said home affairs offices that had been a “nightmare” were Umgeni Road in Durban and Randburg in Johannesburg, which had generated countless complaints because of the “over-subscription” of citizens using these branches.
Motsoaledi said the Pavilion branch offers both appointments and walk-in services and urged the public to take down the names, or even take photographs, of any officials who turn people away.

He added that citizens could also expect a “huge” announcement from home affairs in two week’s time.
Pareto Limited chief executive Malose Kekane said the group had been quick to offer retail space when Motsoaledi announced the department’s mall strategy.
“We realised how important it is to make it easy for the public to access services. There is nothing more important in your wallet than your ID card,” he said.
Kekane then alluded to the suicide of S’khumbuzo Douglas Mhlongo, 22, who he said was a young person who would never be forgotten for his struggle with the home affairs department.
Mhlongo’s body was found in a shack near Hillcrest, KwaZulu-Natal, in 2009, along with a suicide note saying he had taken his life because he could not obtain an ID. He had been unable to take a permanent job he had been offered because he did not have an ID and officials had allegedly asked him to pay a R400 bribe.
Kekane said: “It is not easy to do business with the government, but I have found collaborating with the department of home affairs to be refreshing and businesslike,” Kekane said.
Home Affairs Deputy Minister Njabulo Nzuza said that since last year, more than 1.5 million people had had appointments with the department at bank branches. He said the department had also rolled out 100 mobile unit offices to rural areas and schools and planned to roll out a further 100 units “soon”.
“The purpose of today is to expand our footprint by opening this state-of-the-art office where you are able to come here to apply for your passport and any other services that home affairs offers. We are doing this because the identity of citizens is important for the basic functioning of the economy. If citizens cannot access their ID they cannot enter basic contracts,” he said.
KwaZulu-Natal Premier Nomusa Dube-Ncube said the provincial government had been “concerned” about the state of services at home affairs offices in Pinetown, Umgeni Road and Durban’s city centre because people were exposed to crime, poor access for older people and a lack of ablution facilities.
“We are looking forward to the alleviation of these kinds of conditions people are experiencing in these offices,” Dube-Ncube said.
Other offices opening in KwaZulu-Natal later this year will be in Kwadukuza and Chatsworth.
Submit and get free exposure here: Showcase Your Business | Advertise Your Special Offers.

