Why you are not guaranteed a place at university even if you have the credentials:
The year 2024 will be remembered as the period when South Africa achieved the highest-ever matric pass rate, with 87.3% — surpassing the previous record of 82.9% set in 2023.
But, for most learners and their parents, the excitement has been short-lived. A grim reality has dawned on them: attaining a Bachelor’s admission is not a guarantee for a place at university, even for those achieving higher subject scores.
The increase in the number of learners attaining a Bachelor’s admission pass versus the number of spaces available has become a source of concern for universities.
By way of example, at the University of Johannesburg (UJ), the Faculty of Education received 68 000 applications for 772 first-year spaces. Of the 68 000 applicants, almost 50 000 had bachelor endorsements — still far more than what the university could accommodate. It was a similar situation for most faculties and programmes at UJ.
What most people do not realise is that every public institution of higher learning is restricted by an enrolment plan set in advance with the department of higher education and training (DHET). Public institutions are penalised for over-enrolling and under-enrolling against these targets. Student registrations are thus carefully controlled.
University communication with eligible students is vital under these circumstances.
And, as soon as the grade 12 results were officially released by the minister of basic education, the university admissions office communication process kicked into gear, informing applicants that they had been fully admitted and could register, and others that they had been placed on a waiting list, or unfortunately declined.
In January, thus far, 1.2 million letters, emails and SMSes have already been sent out to applicants. This is when the emails, WhatsApp messages, and other social media commentary intensifies — with many of the messages reflecting the disappointment of some applicants who are not able to register for their qualifications of choice.
As university representatives, we understand how confusing the university systems of admission may be for some applicants.
First, applications for 2025 would have opened in 2024, with most applicants applying on the basis of their final grade 11 results. A learner’s various subject marks (excluding life orientation) are calculated in a particular way, forming what is known as an admission points score (APS).
Over and above this, other eligibility requirements are also considered, such as whether an applicant has maths literacy or maths, and so forth. Using these measures, applications are then ranked from the highest to the lowest scores and candidates are provisionally admitted if they meet the minimum entrance requirements for a programme.
This is where most of the confusion in university communication arises. A provisional admission only means that a candidate meets the minimum requirements for the qualification. Once the grade 12 results are finalised the applications are re-ranked. It is at this point that an applicant’s provisionally admitted status may convert into a fully admit, waiting list, or declined status.
We try to inform applicants at every stage of the process of their admission status and what that means. For example, the provisionally admitted letter to applicants states the following: “… this is not your final application status.
If you meet all the admission requirements and selection criteria with your final grade 12 results, including the subject-specific requirements and the relevant endorsement, your application will be ranked based on your final grade 12 results and space availability.
Best performing applicants will get placed first based on their APS scores, and in accordance with the UJ and DHET approved enrolment management plan. Meeting the minimum admission requirements does not guarantee admission to a qualification.”
In the next stage, applicants with the highest APS scores (and who meet any other requirements) for a particular qualification are filtered into batches and fully admitted. Communication then goes to these applicants to register as soon as possible, because places cannot be reserved or guaranteed.
Those with lower APS scores, but who still meet the minimum requirements, are placed on a waiting list. For example, the minimum APS score for a programme could be 30, with most of the applicants meeting this requirement.
But, in most cases, only the top APS-ranked students above a particular threshold — 36 — are fully admitted. The communication from UJ also warns applicants that the minimum APS score for a programme usually does not provide access to the programme, and gives an indication of the higher APS scores of successful applicants based on history.
The available spaces for programmes are often filled within a day or two, and in some cases, within hours. It is at this point that a second major confusion arises.
If fully admitted candidates are not paying attention to university communication, they may miss their window of opportunity to register and then applicants on the waiting list are awarded a fully admitted status and invited to register. Registration is a time-sensitive process and proceeds on a “first-come-first serve” basis, and spaces cannot be guaranteed.
We try to alert applicants to the importance of registering as soon as they get the notification from the university. For instance, in the admission and registration letters, it is also stated that: “… due to space constraints, registration within the specified registration period is dependent on space availability.
This means that if all spaces are filled before the end of the registration period, registration for the specific qualification will close.”
Should a student cancel his or her registration, the space could be offered to the next ranked applicant on the list. This registration process is mostly automated and subject to auditing to make it as fair and free from human interference as possible.
As many more learners become eligible for university level studies, without additional spaces becoming available in the sector, we are likely to see an increase in the number of applicants who are unable to register and a repeat of the criticisms of university systems.
While the explanation offered in this article may serve as cold comfort to many of our unsuccessful applicants, we hope that it helps give readers an understanding of the process of university admissions followed.
We also want to use this as an opportunity to help applicants, parents and families understand the importance of reading the university correspondence carefully and ensuring that they get the necessary advice at this pressured time.
We encourage young people to look around for other opportunities for post-school learning and development.
Professor Nadine Petersen is executive dean of the Faculty of Education, University of Johannesburg and Dr Tinus van Zyl is the senior director, Central Academic Administration at the University of Johannesburg.
‘Tax is unlikely to deter drinkers’:
The treasury’s proposal last year to increase taxes on alcohol — wine, beer and spirits — in a bid to curb excessive consumption is unlikely to be effective, experts say.
The finance minister, Enoch Godongwana, is expected to make the controversial announcement in his budget speech next month — the first under the coalition government formed last year after the ANC lost its parliamentary majority in the general elections.
Late last year, the treasury proposed setting a minimum price for alcoholic beverages to reduce harmful consumption, which is a drain on the country’s health resources.
According to a policy analysis document released by the department, the minimum unit price would prevent producers and retailers from absorbing some of the tax increase and offering large discounts on alcoholic products.
While raising taxes might increase revenue “to a certain extent”, it might not “encourage behavioural change as the government would have wanted or expected it to” cautioned Evádne Bronkhorst, a chartered tax adviser specialising in indirect taxes at audit firm Forvis Mazars.
“It could actually increase the black market and that would expose South African consumers to buying alcohol that doesn’t meet regulations, which is also not conducive to preserving South African consumers’ health.
“I think the government should be careful in how they go about this and manage it,” she told the Mail & Guardian this week, on the sidelines of a roundtable discussion ahead of the budget.
The treasury opened the proposed tax for public comment in November, saying it was intended to curb road deaths caused by excessive alcohol consumption and to safeguard consumers’ health.
“The harmful use of alcohol is one of the leading risk factors for population health worldwide and has a direct impact on many health-related targets of the sustainable development goals,” the treasury said in the document.
It noted a study conducted by the World Health Organisation which said that, globally, the harmful use of alcohol resulted in more than 3.3 million deaths annually and was one of the causes of diseases and injuries.
According to the treasury, South Africa has been applying an excise tax framework which provides a guideline “for the tax incidence as a percentage of the weighted average retail selling price of alcoholic beverages since 2004”.
Tax incidence refers to who bears the relative burden of a new or existing tax that is levied.
The guideline for the tax incidence for wine, beer and spirits is set at 11%, 23% and 36%, respectively.
When the treasury applies measures, such as the sugar tax which was introduced in 2018, to boost health outcomes, it essentially means some consumers are no longer able to afford the products that contain the offending components, said Althea Soobyah, who is the head of tax at Forvis Mazars.
“On the one hand, you’re trying to curb the fatality rate by increasing the alcohol taxes, and on the other side, what’s the impact of that?
“Who’s going to carry [the tax] from a manufacturer, retailer and alcoholic beverages producer perspective?” Soobyah asked.
She pointed out that one of the results of imposing such taxes on the consumer was that retailers effectively missed out on some revenue — affecting their ability to pay more tax.
The treasury noted that the affordability of alcoholic beverages, determined by their relative price, rates of inflation and consumer income, were considered to be one of the most important factors affecting consumption.
The treasury insists that tax on alcohol and pricing policies are effective tools to reduce consumption by making alcoholic beverages unaffordable to some.
The proposed tax would affect wine, beer and spirits based on their alcohol content. Spirits, which include tequila, rum and gin, would be taxed at a much higher rate than other categories of alcohol.
Wine with low alcohol content would still be assigned the current excise duty rate of R4.96 per litre, while wine with an alcohol content ranging from 4.5% to 9% per litre would be taxed at R6.94 per litre. Wine with a high alcohol content — 9% to 16.5% per litre — would be taxed at R8.93.
But Zandile Makhoba, a consumer economist at Liberty, noted that “alcohol is not a product people reduce consumption of, even when prices increase”.
“(The) downside is that we may start to see consumption of other products decline, to afford the rise of alcohol,” Makhoba told the M&G.
Paddy Harper, the humble warrior:
Monday.
It is 9am and time for the meeting of the Mail & Guardian section heads.
We hardened survivors of the mayhem that has blitzed the media landscape in South Africa are preparing for another week of chasing the news in our turbulent country.
There is the ravenous online beast to be fed and that hardy perennial, the print edition, needs to be planned.
But there is one of those little blocks missing from the Google meeting screen. The name Paddy Harper is not there, and all of us know that somehow we have to come to terms with the void that his sudden death has left.
Paddy was an old-school print journalist with vast experience and a list of contacts, dating back to his activist days, that was the envy of many in the journalism world, particularly the politics reporters.
He knew about deadlines, front-page leads and the joy of the after-work drink when the paper had been put to bed. Usually with his byline on the story that led the paper.
But despite his years, Paddy knew that “digital first” was not just an empty phrase bandied about by desperate media bosses, and his output of daily stories for the online platform was exceptional.
He was always eager to learn, but it was usually the rest of us who learnt from him.
His knowledge, experience and wisdom often made him the voice of reason in the sometimes heated debates among the M&G journalists. Of course, he would deny this.
And then there was his column… The wit and wisdom just seemed to flow out of him like Guinness from the tap in an Irish bar.
I feel ridiculous having my words occupy the space that he owned for so many years.
He was an extraordinary journalist, but I think Paddy was so loved because he was just such a great human being.
Paddy was “a genuine guy”, says M&G photographer Delwyn Verasamy, who spent many hours traversing the KwaZulu-Natal North and South Coasts on assignment with him.
They shared a love of fishing and Paddy would always tell him to “bring the rods”. Of course they never found time to fish because the dedicated newshound was too busy chasing the story.
Paddy and I grew up in Durban and we shared a love of the weed that has always been so readily available in the province.
Paddy’s enjoyment of the herbal remedy in all its forms, and the twinkle in his eyes that revealed his Irish roots, often made me regret giving up the marijuana habit. Maybe if I started again I could be more like Paddy.
His passing has once again made me think of the randomness and unfairness of death. The good ones always go too soon.
During the Christmas period a friend who I have known for 30 years was killed in a car accident while travelling down to Durban. An out-of-control car came flying across from the opposite lane and crashed onto the roof of her car on the driver’s side. One second either way and she would still be alive.
I just can’t stop thinking that I didn’t make enough time to enjoy her company while she was alive. And the same goes for Paddy.
We spoke almost every working day but, because he was in Durban, there was never the opportunity to just be two old geezers chewing the fat. Or better still chewing on a mutton bunny chow from Goundens in Umbilo.
Maybe some day the gaping hole left by his death will be papered over. Maybe the pain in our hearts will recede.
Maybe.
Submit and get free exposure here: Showcase Your Business | Advertise Your Special Offers.

